Stillwater - Car Insurance

Compare all car insurance quotes in one place

Compare Quotes

Personalized quotes in less than 2 minutes.

No signup required

As we work together to slow the spread of COVID-19, state insurance commissions and insurance providers are constantly changing regulations and practices surrounding monthly payments, claim payouts, and more. To stay up to date with the latest on auto insurance reimbursements in your area, be sure to check with your state’s insurance commission and your current auto insurance provider.

If your driving habits have changed due to COVID-19, find a new, cheaper, ready-to-buy auto insurance policy on Insurify by comparing dozens of quotes at once.



Composite Score
Not Rated
What is this?
Stillwater Ratings
BrandRatingsUser reviews


The largest discounts from Stillwater are: Good Driver Discount, Anti-Theft Device Discount, Good Student Discount

Loading Chart
Discount TypeDiscount %
Good Driver DiscountVaries
Anti-Theft Device DiscountVaries
Good Student DiscountVaries
Accident Free DiscountVaries
Multiple Policy DiscountVaries
Multiple Vehicle DiscountVaries
Paid in full discountVaries
Paperless documents discountVaries
Anti-lock Brake DiscountVaries
Passive Restraint DiscountVaries

Payment methods

  • complete-tick.svg
    Online Payment

Features and Services

Stillwater's auto insurance offerings are straightforward (it offers bodily injury and property damage liability insurance, like all other competitors), but the company's auto insurance carrier subsidiary also offers comprehensive and collision coverage, rental car insurance, and roadside assistance. Stillwater representatives, claims examiners, and insurance agents are available to start the claims process via phone call 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

  • benefit/247service.svg
    24/7 service
  • benefit/roadside-assistance.svg
    Roadside assistance
  • benefit/online-portal.svg
    Online account management

Car Insurance Coverage

Not seeing the state you're looking for? See all states here.

Optional Coverage

  • complete-tick.svg
    Roadside Assistance
  • complete-tick.svg
    Rental Reimbursement
  • complete-tick.svg
    Comprehensive Claim Forgiveness

SR‌-22 Insurance by State

Stillwater Insurance Products

Car Insurance
Business Insurance
Condo Insurance
Earthquake Insurance
Home Insurance
Renters Insurance
Umbrella Insurance

FAQs - Stillwater Car Insurance

How does Insurify work?

Insurify lets you freely compare accurate car insurance quotes and discounts from top national and regional insurance companies in a matter of minutes. You can choose between coverage levels and adjust deductibles to ensure you're not just getting the cheapest policy, but the most appropriate one, too. Users save an average of $489 a year when they buy a new insurance policy through Insurify.

How does Insurify find me the cheapest car insurance quotes?

Think of Insurify as your personalized, online insurance agent. Insurify's platform uses the latest in AI to match you with real, accurate, and bindable car insurance quotes based on your driver history and budget. Insurify is not an insurance company and will not share the information you share on the site with any third party.

How is Insurify different from other insurance quote comparison sites?

Insurify is the top-rated and most-rated insurance comparison website in America. Unlike comparison sites that just take your information and sell it to the highest bidder, Insurify is built on trust and empowerment. No matter your license record, budget, or regional background, Insurify is committed to securing the cheapest and best deals that work for you.

Compare Stillwater to GEICO

Stillwater vs GEICO

Company History

Stillwater Insurance Group, formerly known as Fidelity National Property & Insurance Group (a subsidiary of Fidelity National Financial), was founded in 2000. Stillwater Insurance Group is made up of Stillwater Insurance Company, Stillwater Insurance Services, Inc., and Stillwater Property & Casualty Insurance Company.

Stillwater Insurance Company offers personal auto insurance policies in 18 states and is "coming soon" to 7 more. It also offers other personal and commercial coverages in all 50 states, including home insurance, renters insurance, condo insurance, landlord insurance, and earthquake and umbrella policies. 

Stillwater boasts a Better Business Bureau rating of A+. In addition, the independent financial health assessor A.M. Best gives Stillwater a financial strength rating of A-, signifying its excellent financial security and ability to pay out claims.

Contact Information

Headquarters addresses: 

4905 Belfort Road, Suite 110 Jacksonville, Florida 32256

12500 I Street, Suite 100 Omaha, Nebraska 68137

5385 Hollister Avenue, Building 13 Santa Barbara, California 93111

Phone numbers: 

Home, auto, and umbrella insurance - (855) 712-4092

Business insurance - (855) 712-4114

Claims - (800) 220-1351

New agent appointment - (866) 663-7129

Stillwater Reviews

5 Stars
100 %

Most Positive Review

By Dennis

Latest Review

By Dennis

All Reviews

Showing 1 - 1 out of 1 Reviews
Sort by

Read reviews that mention


Stillwater Car Insurance Information

Insurify Composite Score0
Number of discounts10
Number of reviews1
User Rating5