Browse. Compare. Discover. Let Insurify find the best car insurance deals for you in The Hoosier State.
24,000
Followers
4.8 Rating
2,700 Reviews
12 Million
Quotes
Perhaps no other state takes driving more seriously than the state of Indiana. The Indianapolis Motor Speedway is home to the famous Indy 500 and the United States’ first long-distance auto race in 1911. Carmel City boasts more roundabouts—124 and counting as of April this year—than any other city in the country. Up north, you’ll find the R.V./Motorhome Hall of Fame, a museum and event space dedicated to homes on wheels.
And if that doesn’t entice you, then how about Holiday World—a holiday-themed theme park located in Santa Claus, Indiana? Like the rest of the state, it comes with stick-to-your-ribs comfort foods, fried whenever possible.
Here are the cheapest carriers in Indiana for the following user profile: a single, 30 year old male with a clean driving record who drives a 2012 Honda Accord and pays a $1,000 deductible for the state’s minimum liability insurance. We averaged rates for the twenty most populous cities in Indiana.
| Cheapest Companies | Quotes |
|---|---|
 Progressive | $23/mo |
 State Farm | $51/mo |
 Allstate | $87/mo |
 Travelers | $95/mo |
 Nationwide | $106/mo |
The Insurify Composite Score is calculated by analyzing multiple factors that indicate the quality, reliability, and health of an insurance company. Inputs to the score include financial strength ratings from A.M. Best, Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s, and Fitch; J.D. Power ratings, Consumer Reports customer satisfaction surveys, mobile app reviews, and user-generated carrier reviews. The following are the top rated carriers that offer car insurance in Indiana. For the complete list, see Insurify's best car insurance companies.
| Best Companies | Quotes | |
|---|---|---|
Nationwide | $106/mo | |
 American Family | $151/mo | |
State Farm | $51/mo | |
Allstate | $87/mo | |
 Liberty Mutual | $126/mo | |
Progressive | $23/mo | |
Travelers | $95/mo |
Auto insurance costs will vary between locations and insurance carriers. Insurify analyzed the latest data for the five most populous cities in Indiana to find you the cheapest quotes in each of these metropolitan areas.
Indiana's capital, Indianapolis, is the state's most populous city. The state currently oversees a $3 billion project to extend the I-69 highway from Evansville to Indianapolis. Indianapolis drivers rank among the worst in the nation, according to Insurify's 2018 study of top cities with the worst drivers.
| City | Cheapest Carrier | Quote |
|---|---|---|
| Indianapolis | Progressive | $52/mo |
| Fort Wayne | Progressive | $44/mo |
| Evansville | Progressive | $39/mo |
| South Bend | Progressive | $36/mo |
| Carmel | Progressive | $37/mo |
| Fishers | Progressive | $26/mo |
| Bloomington | Progressive | $25/mo |
| Hammond | Progressive | $31/mo |
| Gary | Progressive | $32/mo |
| Lafayette | Progressive | $23/mo |
| Muncie | Progressive | $24/mo |
| Terre Haute | Progressive | $27/mo |
| Noblesville | Progressive | $24/mo |
| Kokomo |  State Farm | $64/mo |
| Anderson | State Farm | $59/mo |
| Greenwood | State Farm | $63/mo |
| Elkhart | State Farm | $53/mo |
| Mishawaka | State Farm | $60/mo |
| Jeffersonville | State Farm | $79/mo |
| New Albany |  Clearcover | $81/mo |
| West Lafayette | Clearcover | $74/mo |
Indiana drivers must purchase car insurance and must carry proof of financial responsibility in their vehicles. Unlike many states, Indiana requires uninsured motorist protection in addition to property damage liability and bodily injury liability coverage.
Motorists are required to purchase auto insurance coverage meeting these minimums:
Here are the cheapest insurance companies in Indiana based on averaged sample rates for four driver profiles that included varied gender, age, driving history, credit, marital status, prior insurance, higher education, employment, and military service. Average rates may vary depending on the profile and background of the policyholder.
For Indiana drivers with a clean driving record free of any moving violations, auto insurance rates may be significantly lower. Progressive offers the best options for good drivers in Indiana, at $23 a month. With both cheaper premiums and additional safe driving discounts, it can really pay to have a record free of accidents or traffic tickets.
| Insurance Company | Quotes |
|---|---|
Progressive | $23/mo |
State Farm | $51/mo |
Allstate | $87/mo |
Travelers | $95/mo |
Nationwide | $106/mo |
Everybody makes mistakes and has to deal with the fallout. The fallout for a DUI is rough: court fines, reinstatement fees, SR-22 filing, and years of paying more for car insurance to name only a few. Finding affordable rates on car insurance with a DUI is no small feat. If you find yourself really struggling to get an affordable rate, consider only carrying liability coverage as a way to save.
| Insurance Company | Quotes |
|---|---|
State Farm | $31/mo |
Indiana Farmers Mutual | $32/mo |
Erie | $34/mo |
The sinking feeling after realizing you’ve caused an accident is no exaggeration. Even a tiny fender bender can raise rates to levels that significantly alter your budget. If you’ve paid for accident forgiveness you may have caught a break. If not: discounts, discounts, discounts.
And comparison shopping at least every time your policy is up for renewal: insurance companies look at different time windows for driving history. For example, one company might look at the last five years while the other looks at the last three. Here are the best rates we could find for drivers with one at-fault accident.
| Insurance Company | Quotes |
|---|---|
Buckeye | $18/mo |
Erie | $21/mo |
Celina | $28/mo |
The need for speed can soon turn into the need for a new budget. Speeding tickets can affect people differently. But essentially, the more often you speed—and the higher your mph—the more points you’ll receive on your driver’s license. Higher points mean higher prices in the car insurance game. The best way to lower costs? Slow down and find a discount program, like a defensive driving course reduction.
| Insurance Company | Quotes |
|---|---|
Erie | $21/mo |
USAA | $28/mo |
Buckeye | $29/mo |
If you’re under 40 years old in the state of Indiana, you will likely pay more for auto insurance coverage than the average driver. Since inexperienced drivers pose a higher risk for insurance providers, their rates are often significantly higher. Buckeye offers the cheapest car insurance rates for young drivers, averaging $19 a month. New drivers must abide by special driving restrictions, including curfews, electronic device limitations, and passenger age restrictions. Be sure to familiarize yourself with these rules before hitting the road.
Insurance policies for 21-year-olds generally run higher than the national average by a significant margin. Even though they’re no longer considered teen-drivers, 21-year-olds are still regarded as high-risk to insurers. Unlike most states, Indiana 21-year-olds benefit from the state’s ban on using gender, education level, and credit score as factors when calculating premiums. This will generally help young Hoosiers lower their monthly payments. To find the cheapest car insurance for 21-year-olds, use a car insurance quotes comparison site like Insurify.
| Insurance Company | Quotes |
|---|---|
Buckeye | $19/mo |
Erie | $21/mo |
Celina | $22/mo |
Cincinnati | $24/mo |
USAA | $44/mo |
If your license has been suspended or revoked, these car insurance companies will file an SR-22 with the state of Indiana on your behalf.
You’ll need to go to the Indiana Bureau of Motor Vehicles, but not as often as you might in other states. Every driver has the opportunity to create an online account where they can renew the registration, view their driving records, schedule appointments, and more.
Indiana is serious about BMV access. It has even installed several 24-hour self-service terminals known as BMV Connect. You can pay fees, renew IDs, even register a new vehicle at the kiosk. It’s pretty incredible.
Transferring your license to Indiana is easy to do, and you’ll have 60 days to do so once you move. Just be sure to look up the hours for your local BMV as it does not have uniform hours. If you’ve recently moved to the Hoosier State, you can print out the easy-to-follow New Indiana Resident Packet and follow the checklists.
Emissions inspections are required in Lake and Porter country—the part of Indiana where residents are part of the Chicago metro area known as Chicagoland. Testing done at state-run sites does not require a fee. Drivers who choose to go to an independent site for testing may pay a convenience fee.
Using a proprietary dataset of over 1.5 million car insurance shopper applications, the data scientists at Insurify have run various studies on driver behavior across geographical locations, age ranges, motor vehicle registration, and other variables all related to auto insurance coverage.
We've been able to determine the speediest cities in the nation, the most popular cars among age groups, and the occupations with the worst drivers, among other insightful reports. We've also launched annual awards campaigns to congratulate the communities across the country who have excelled in environmentally friendly initiatives, educational attainment, and other areas.
The EPA reports that the United States' transportation sector accounts for 27% of national greenhouse gas emissions. In a country of over 263 million registered vehicles, many communities are taking action to reduce their environmental impact and vehicular carbon footprint. This city has been named the "greenest" in the state by Insurify.
The Indiana Department of Environmental Management and Hoosier Environmental Council are among the many groups advancing green initiatives in Indiana. The state consistently ranks relatively low for eco-friendliness and quality of life, but some parts of the state are clear exceptions to the rule. The state of Indiana offers many green driver incentives, including federal tax credits, rebates, and discounts through some car insurance carriers.
Beginning in 2018, Insurify launched the Most Patriotic Cities Awards, which salute the community in each state with the highest percentage of individuals who currently serve in the military or identify as armed service veterans.
Anderson won Insurify's Most Patriotic Cities Award for the state of Indiana. McClain's Historical Military Armory Museum is closing its doors after over 25 years, and is projected to be a blow to the local economy.
Insurify used a recent report from TripNet to rank twenty-five states by roads in poor condition, structurally deficient bridges, and fatality rate per 100 million vehicle miles traveled (VMT) on rural roads. Knowledge of infrastructure in Indiana is vital for all car insurance shoppers hitting the road in The Hoosier State.
