Best Car Insurance Companies in Florida 2022 | Quotes, Discounts

Looking for cheap car insurance from the best company for Florida drivers? Look no further than this list. We reviewed nearly one million quotes, hundreds of reviews, and dozens of company websites to give you the best Florida auto insurance companies.

Keep in mind that Florida is a no-fault state and that minimum car insurance requirements are low compared to the national average. According to Florida law, these coverage requirements are:

• Property damage liability insurance (PDL/PD): $10,000 per accident

• Personal injury protection (PIP): $10,000 per accident

But you may need additional coverage and/or higher coverage limits to ensure you’re protected. This can include:

• Collision coverage

• Comprehensive coverage

• Bodily injury liability

• Underinsured and uninsured motorist coverage

Getting the best deal that the great state of Florida has to offer is easy with Insurify. Fill out one short and confidential form and get free car insurance quotes tailored to your exact needs. When the price is right, purchase your new policy quickly and easily. Try it now! Not ready to commit to a quote? Check out our car insurance estimator to see how much you should expect to pay.

Best Car Insurance Companies 2022

Insurify Composite Score Methodology

The Insurify Composite Score is a proprietary rating calculated by a team of data scientists at Insurify, weighing multiple factors that reflect the quality, reliability, and health of an insurance company.

Inputs to the score include financial strength ratings from A.M. Best, Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s, and Fitch; J.D. Power ratings; Consumer Reports customer satisfaction surveys and customer complaints; mobile app reviews; and user-generated company reviews.

Top Car Insurance Companies: Find the Right One for You

As you review the pros and cons of each car insurance provider, please keep your unique needs in mind. The best company, in general, may not be the best fit for you. It’s important to ask yourself, “how much car insurance do I need” before you start your search, but Insurify can help you select your desired coverage options. So let this list guide you, but remember: it’s just a guide. Find out the average car insurance cost for top companies here.

1

Safeco

Safeco is part of the Liberty Mutual family. Though it is one of the largest insurers on its own, it doesn’t receive the same attention as other big companies. So let’s make sure it’s on your radar when shopping for a policy.

Safeco offers competitive auto insurance rates, though not the lowest rates in town. However, Safeco receives far fewer complaints than average in the auto insurance field. It also offers a huge range of customized policies, discount options, and additional perks. But, even with these options, Safeco receives lower-than-average customer satisfaction ratings.

As an added note, Safeco is a great choice for people who work in the rideshare business - Uber and Lyft drivers for example.

Top discounts from Safeco include:

• Safety features

• Multi-car

• Safe driver

• Multi-policy

• Homeowner

• Low mileage

• Theft-deterrent

• RightTrack

• Preventive driving course

• Good student

• Distant student

• Pay in full

Here are the average quotes Safeco offers by driver profile:

2

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual offers a wide variety of insurance products. That means you’ll have a ton of car insurance options in addition to options for other insurance needs. On the other hand, Liberty Mutual has lower-than-average customer satisfaction and higher-than-average customer complaints.

Plus, Liberty Mutual is not known for its low premiums. In fact, based on the quoting history at Insurify, Liberty Mutual has some of the most expensive policies in Florida.

But for your money, you will receive a quality full-coverage policy. Plus, you can offset the higher costs by taking advantage of the many insurance discounts offered or by adjusting your deductible.

Top discounts from Liberty Mutual include:

• Homeowner

• Military

• Early shopper

• Good student

• Student away at school

• Advanced safety features

• Alternative energy

• Anti-theft

• Accident-free

• Violation-free

• RightTrack

• Multi-policy

• Multi-car

• Preferred payment

• Pay in full

• Online purchase

• Paperless

Here are the average quotes Liberty Mutual offers by driver profile:

3

Travelers

Travelers is one of the largest insurance providers in the nation. You’ll find a wide array of coverage options - both for your car and for many other property insurance needs. That means you can access multi-policy (bundling) discounts, which typically offer drivers the best rates. And Travelers also offers valuable products like gap coverage and umbrella insurance.

Travelers doesn’t have the highest average customer satisfaction rating. In fact, it’s lower than the industry average. Even so, Travelers receives fewer customer complaints than average.

Top discounts for Travelers policyholders include:

• Multi-policy

• Multi-car

• Homeowners

• Safe driver

• Continuous insurance

• Hybrid/electric car

• New car

• EFT, pay in full, good payer

• Early quote

• Good student

• Student away at school

• Driver training

• Affinity membership

• IntelliDrive® program

Here are the average quotes Travelers offers by driver profile:

4

National General

If you’re a high-risk driver, National General should make your list of prospective insurers. While the company has received more customer complaints than average, it does provide competitive rates for drivers who need SR-22 or FR-44 coverage. And if you’re an SR-22 or FR-44 driver, you can get discounts for completing safe driving and substance abuse courses.

Drivers with histories of dropped policies, failures to pay, poor credit scores, and car accidents can also benefit from discounts not offered at the average company. However, you won’t have access to a mobile app. And the company website is less than optimal.

Top discounts from National General include:

• Paid in full

• Multi-vehicle

• Safe driver

• RV and auto combined policy

• Low mileage

• Affinity membership

• Multi-policy

• Paperless

• Auto-pay

• Anti-theft

Here are the average quotes National General offers by driver profile:

5

AssuranceAmerica

Here’s another insurer tailor-made for high-risk drivers. AssuranceAmerica specializes in insuring people with a driving history that includes multiple infractions and DUIs. Additionally, from our research, we can see that among high-risk insurers, AssuranceAmerica offers the lowest insurance premiums on average.

You’ll find an easy-to-use website and 24/7 customer service care with this company. However, there have been a higher-than-average number of customer complaints. Even so, the Better Business Bureau gives AssuranceAmerica an A+ rating.

Top discounts from AssuranceAmerica include:

• Homeowners

• Continuous coverage

• Military

• Warehouse clubs

• Multi-car

• Defensive driver certification

• Paid in full

• Good student

Here are the average quotes AssuranceAmerica offers by driver profile:

6

Progressive

Affordable car insurance from a large provider? With Progressive, it’s possible. With a big company come big investments in ease-of-use technology - for managing both policies and claims. And, for such a large company, Progressive has fewer complaints than the average.

Bundling home insurance with car insurance is a great way to save money with Progressive. Young drivers will also find great discounts. And, if you’re looking for a tech-forward company with tons of helpful tools and an easy-to-use app, Progressive has what you need.

Top discounts from Progressive include:

• Multi-policy

• Multi-car

• Continuous insurance

• Snapshot (safe driver)

• Teen driver

• Good student

• Distant student

• Homeowner

• Online quote

• Sign online

• Paperless

• Pay in full

• Automatic payment

Here are the average quotes Progressive offers by driver profile:

7

Direct Auto

Direct Auto offers affordable auto insurance policies for high-risk drivers in Florida. The company has more complaints than the average insurer - which is saying a lot because the insurance industry as a whole receives a high number of complaints.

However, if you’re a driver with a spotty driving record or you’ve been denied auto insurance coverage in the past, Direct Auto may be the right choice for you. You can find easy SR-22 coverage here, and you can access a wide range of discounts.

Top discounts from Direct Auto include:

• Military discount

• Safe driver

• Good student

• Senior citizen

• Multi-car

• Multi-product

• Prior coverage

• Homeowner

• Renewal

• Welcome back

• Affinity membership

Here are the average quotes Direct Auto offers by driver profile:

Average Monthly Cost of Car Insurance in Florida

Whether you live in the Sunshine State or elsewhere, car insurance rates vary greatly depending on your location. Claim rates, crime rates, and climate can all impact what you pay. Below, we show the average car insurance quotes for the 10 largest cities in Florida. How do your insurance costs stack up?

How to Determine the Best Car Insurance Company for Yourself

In the end, it’s not about going with the best auto insurance company but the best company for you. You should consider your particular needs and preferences when choosing a company, such as:

• Budget

• Website and app preferences

• Discounts you qualify for

• Customer service needs

There are many well-rated Florida car insurance companies, so be sure to choose what fits best over what’s ranked best. You can compare car insurance quotes on Insurify. Notable insurers that did not make this list but should be on your radar include:

• USAA

• GEICO

• Allstate

• State Farm