insurify
  • Compare Quotes

    Start Search

  • Menu
    • Car Insurance
    • Home Insurance
    • Virtual Agent
    • About
    • Blog
  • Car Insurance Home Insurance Virtual Agent About Blog
  • Start Saving
insurify
insurify
  • Start saving now

Auto-Owners vs Progressive Car Insurance

Compare quotes from 10+ companies in one place Compare Quotes

  Personalized quotes in less than 2 minutes.

  No signup required

Ratings

Insurify Composite Score Auto-Owners
VS Progressive
What's this?
Insurify Composite ScoreProgressive
What's this?
Compare Quotes
User Ratings
Options Auto-Owners Progressive
Rating/Reviews
Full Star Full Star Half Star Empty Star Empty Star
62 reviews
Full Star Full Star Half Star Empty Star Empty Star
2,969 reviews
U.S Auto Insurance Shopping Study (2018)
Options Auto-Owners Progressive
Overall Satisfaction Better than most About average
Policy Offerings Among the best About average
Pricing Better than most About average
Local Agent Among the best About average
Call Center Representative -- The rest
Insurer Website -- About average
U.S Auto Insurance Claims Satisfaction Study (2018)
Options Auto-Owners Progressive
Overall Satisfaction Better than most About average
First Notice of Loss (FNOL) Better than most About average
Claim Servicing Better than most About average
Estimation Process Better than most About average
Repair Process About average About average
Rental Experience Among the best Better than most
Settlement Better than most About average
J.D. Power Ratings by Region (out of 1000)
Region Auto-Owners Progressive
Florida
812 pt
About average
812 pt
About average
Southeast
842 pt
Better than most
830 pt
About average
North Central
850 pt
Among the best
818 pt
The rest
Central
847 pt
Better than most
815 pt
The rest
Southwest --
812 pt
About average
Texas --
815 pt
The rest
Mid-Atlantic --
835 pt
About average
New England --
826 pt
About average
California --
800 pt
About average
New York --
816 pt
About average
Northwest --
808 pt
About average
Mobile App Ratings
Brand Auto-Owners Progressive
iOS
Full Star Full Star Full Star Half Star Empty Star
6 reviews
Full Star Full Star Full Star Half Star Empty Star
317 reviews
Android
Full Star Full Star Full Star Full Star Half Star
20 reviews
Full Star Full Star Full Star Full Star Half Star
17,106 reviews
Financial Ratings
Company Name Auto-Owners Progressive
A.M. Best A++ A+
Standard & Poor's -- A
Fitch -- A+
Moody's -- A2

Auto Insurance Quotes

For Married Drivers

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $61 $56
Philadelphia $67 $58
Phoenix $35 $55
Los Angeles -- $45

For Single Drivers

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $65 $76
Philadelphia $68 $75
Phoenix $39 $70
Los Angeles -- $77

For Male Drivers

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $56 $63
Philadelphia $64 $64
Phoenix $32 $60
Los Angeles -- $68

For Female Drivers

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $70 $69
Philadelphia $71 $70
Phoenix $42 $65
Los Angeles -- $54

For Drivers with a Speeding Ticket

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $97 $82
Philadelphia $80 $83
Phoenix $55 $75
Los Angeles -- $84

For Drivers with No Speeding Ticket

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $56 $63
Philadelphia $66 $64
Phoenix $33 $60
Los Angeles -- $56

For Drivers Age Between 18-40

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $64 $75
Philadelphia $67 $74
Phoenix $40 $70
Los Angeles -- $82

For Drivers Age Between 40-65

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $56 $52
Philadelphia $61 $54
Phoenix $31 $51
Los Angeles -- $43

For Drivers Age of 65+

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $83 $87
Philadelphia $90 $84
Phoenix $49 $82
Los Angeles -- $52

For Drivers with Average Credit

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $77 $81
Philadelphia $70 $78
Phoenix $48 $74
Los Angeles -- $62

For Drivers with Fair Credit

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $68 $78
Philadelphia $80 $77
Phoenix $40 $73
Los Angeles -- $55

For Drivers with Good Credit

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $59 $46
Philadelphia $59 $50
Phoenix $34 $47
Los Angeles -- $43

For Drivers with Excellent Credit

City Auto-Owners Progressive
Chicago $48 $59
Philadelphia $60 $62
Phoenix $26 $58
Los Angeles -- $84

Quotes & Discounts

Discount Type Auto-Owners Progressive
Passive Restraint Discount
up to 35%
up to 10%
Multiple Vehicle Discount
up to 31%
up to 30%
Student Away at School Discount
up to 25%
up to 10%
Multiple Policy Discount
up to 14%
up to 10%
Prepay Discount
up to 14%
Varies
Anti-Theft Device Discount
up to 11%
up to 5%
Anti-lock Brake Discount
up to 10%
--
Good Student Discount
up to 10%
up to 10%
Company Car Discount
up to 5%
--
Accident Free Discount
Varies
--
Good Driver Discount
Varies
up to 26%
Paid in full discount
Varies
Varies
Mature driver discount
Varies
--
E-billing Discount
Varies
Varies
Good Credit Discount
Varies
up to 84%
Organization Discount
Varies
--
teenSMART Discount
Varies
Varies
EV/Hybrid Discount
Varies
--
Paperless documents discount
Varies
Varies
Starting your auto quote online discount
--
Varies
Signing documents when you buy online discount
--
Varies
No lapse in coverage discount
--
Varies
Discount Finder
--
Varies
Defensive Driver Discount
--
Varies
Low Mileage Discount
--
Varies
Military Discount
--
Varies
Loyalty Discount
--
Varies
Continuous Coverage Discount
--
Varies
Youth Driving Discount
--
Varies
Preferred payment discount
--
Varies
Home Owner Discount
--
Varies
Provider Switch Discount
--
Varies
Compare Quotes

Payment Methods

Payment Type Auto-Owners Progressive
Automatic Online Payment Complete Tick Complete Tick
Online Payment
--
Complete Tick
Mobile App Payments
--
Complete Tick
Phone Payment
--
Complete Tick
Mail Payment
--
Complete Tick
Credit Card Payment
--
Complete Tick
PayPal
--
Complete Tick
Electronic Check
--
Complete Tick
Text Payment
--
Complete Tick

Feature and Services

Features and Services Auto-Owners Progressive
Roadside assistance Complete Tick Complete Tick
Online account management Complete Tick Complete Tick
Policy bundling discounts Complete Tick
--
Mobile app Complete Tick Complete Tick
24/7 service Complete Tick Complete Tick
Accident forgiveness
--
Complete Tick
Loyalty rewards program
--
Complete Tick

Optional Coverages

Coverage Type Auto-Owners Progressive
Glass Coverage Complete Tick Complete Tick
Gap Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
Pet Coverage Complete Tick Complete Tick
Rental Reimbursement Complete Tick Complete Tick
Roadside Assistance Complete Tick Complete Tick
Antique or Collector Car Insurance Complete Tick
--
Umbrella Policy Complete Tick
--
Accident Forgiveness
--
Complete Tick
Emergency Lockout Coverage
--
Complete Tick
Original Equipment Manufacturer Coverage
--
Complete Tick
Ridesharing Coverage
--
Complete Tick

Insurance by State

  • Car Insurance
  • Life Insurance
  • Umbrella Insurance
  • Motorcycle Insurance
  • Renters Insurance
  • Home / Condo Insurance
  • Auto-Owners
  • Progressive
  • Both

Uber and Lyft driver insurance:

  • Auto-Owners
  • Progressive
  • Both

SR‌-22 Insurance by State

  • Auto-Owners
  • Progressive
  • Both

Compare Insurance Products

Product Auto-Owners Progressive
  ATV Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Boat Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Business Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Car Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Cell Phone Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Classic Car Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Commercial Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Condo Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Flood Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Golf Cart Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Health Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Home Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Homeshare Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Identity Theft Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Life Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Mobile Home Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Motorcycle Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Personal Watercraft Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Pet Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  RV Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Renters Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Segway Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Snowmobile insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Travel Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Umbrella Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Wedding and Event Insurance
--
Complete Tick

Popular Comparisons

  • Auto-Owners vs State Farm
  • Allstate vs Auto-Owners
  • Auto-Owners vs GEICO
  • Progressive vs Safeco
  • Kemper vs Progressive
  • National General vs Progressive

User Reviews

  • Auto-Owners Reviews
  • Progressive Reviews
★ ★★ ★★
2.8
62 user reviews
5 Stars
32% Complete
32%
4 Stars
6% Complete
6%
3 Stars
11% Complete
11%
2 Stars
6% Complete
6%
1 Star
43% Complete
43%
Write a Review
Most Positive Review
★ ★★ ★★
By Dixie
February 13, 2018

Their staff is always friendly, answer all my questions, and I may stay with them. I'm just researching because my rates are so high. I can understand them raising my payments as I've had two accidents since December 19, 2016, but no one was hurt or killed (THANK GOD)it was my only accident in 73 years, damage to both vehicles was under $9,000. My second accident only involved me. Auto-Owners totaled my vehicle and paid me damages of $6206.80. Again, I can see where my rates would raise, I just didn't expect it to be what it is, so I thought I'd shop around.

Most Critical Review
★ ★★ ★★
By Donna
January 9, 2018

Claims Adjuster for 1 thing. Most of the time you can't get ahold of anyone at my agents office

★ ★★ ★★
2.9
2,969 user reviews
5 Stars
24% Complete
24%
4 Stars
9% Complete
9%
3 Stars
8% Complete
8%
2 Stars
18% Complete
18%
1 Star
42% Complete
42%
Write a Review
Most Positive Review
Great discounts, Decent customer service
★ ★★ ★★
By Insurify User
September 17, 2015

I did quite a bit of shopping around when I was in the market for insurance, and Progressive offered the best price out of the major brands (Liberty Mutual, Geico, Allstate, etc). The Liberty Mutual quote was actually so outrageous that I laughed out loud before promptly hanging up on the representative. After signing on with Progressive I called to make sure that I was taking advantage of every discount possible, and also signed up for the snapshot program, which ended up saving me an additional 20% (which was huge). If you don't drive crazy mileage, generally avoid driving at dangerous times (i.e. rush hour), and minimize "hard stops", you're likely to save a significant amount of cash through the Snapshot discount. From a customer service standpoint I've been relatively happy with Progressive, although they did go ghost on me in the middle of a liability investigation after my car was damaged during a tow. No major claims since I've been with them, but minor repairs and some glass work have gone smoothly. Overall I'd recommend Progressive to price-conscious drivers looking for standard coverage and discount options (Snapshot is legit).

Most Critical Review
★ ★★ ★★
By LAURA
October 23, 2017

They are not pro customer. I felt very cheated and we had a terrible agent. The quotes were not accurate and when we added and then removed a vehicle our policy didn't go back to what it originally was. They charged us more for the same policy. Terrible. I will not recommend to anyone.

insurify

Don't miss saving $400 on your car insurance

Compare Quotes

insurify Blog

10 Best & Worst Sites to Compare Car Insurance Quotes 10 Best Auto Insurance Companies for Uber and Lyft Drivers 10 Best Car Insurance Companies of 2019 10 Best & Worst Sites to Compare Home Insurance Quotes The Ultimate Guide to SR-22 Car Insurance
About Blog Careers Press Reviews Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Help

Top Car Insurance Companies

21st Century Amica Dairyland Esurance
Farmers The General The Hartford Liberty Mutual
Mercury MetLife Nationwide Plymouth Rock
Safeco Travelers USAA All companies

Compare Car Insurance Companies

GEICO vs NJ Manufacturers
Farm Bureau Financial Services vs USAA
GEICO vs Root
AAA vs Ameriprise
GEICO vs Travelers
GEICO vs USAA
State Farm vs Travelers
Auto-Owners vs State Farm

Car Insurance By City

Atlanta, GA Charleston, SC Charlotte, NC Chicago, IL Columbus, OH Dallas, TX Denver, CO Houston, TX Jacksonville, FL Las Vegas, NV Los Angeles, CA Memphis, TN Miami, FL Orlando, FL Philadelphia, PA Phoenix, AZ San Antonio, TX San Diego, CA Tampa, FL

Car Insurance By State

AK AL AR AZ CA CO CT DC DE FL GA HI IA ID IL IN KS KY LA MA MD ME MI MN MO MS MT NC ND NE NH NJ NM NV NY OH OK OR PA RI SC SD TN TX UT VA VT WA WI WV WY

© 2013-2019 Insurify, Inc. All rights reserved. Ensurify Insurance Agency is a licensed insurance agency in 50 states.