4.8out of 3,000+ reviews

Compare Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual: Quotes, Discounts (2022)

Secure. Free. Easy-to-use.
Advertising disclosures
auto insurance

Why you can trust Insurify

Insurify partners with top insurance companies and is a licensed agent in all 50 states. However, the insurance experts writing our content operate independently of our partners. Check out reviews from over 3,000 satisfied customers, how we make money, our data methodology, and our editorial standards.
Courtney Roy

By: Courtney Roy

Edited by Tanveen Vohra

Last Updated August 5, 2022

Why you can trust Insurify

Insurify partners with top insurance companies and is a licensed agent in all 50 states. However, the insurance experts writing our content operate independently of our partners. Check out reviews from over 3,000 satisfied customers, how we make money, our data methodology, and our editorial standards.

Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual: A Summary

Allstate and Liberty Mutual are two of the most successful companies by market share in the auto insurance industry, thanks mainly to their financial stability and solid coverage. Yet, both insurance companies have relative strengths and weaknesses. We’ve analyzed the data so you can compare car insurance providers and make an informed decision.

Insurance ProviderAvg. Monthly Car Insurance QuoteInsurify Composite Score
Allstate$5882
Liberty Mutual$24782

ICS Score Explanation:

The Insurify Composite Score (ICS) is a proprietary rating calculated by a team of data scientists at Insurify, weighing multiple factors that reflect the quality, reliability, and health of an insurance company.

Inputs to the score include financial strength ratings from A.M. Best, Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s, and Fitch; J.D. Power ratings; Consumer Reports customer satisfaction surveys and customer complaints; mobile app reviews; and user-generated company reviews.

Allstate

Allstate is one of the few insurers in the country with local agents and coverage to match. The company’s features and benefits include discounts for bundling other products like homeowners insurance and a Drivewise telematics program that rewards safe driving habits with lower prices.

Pros

  • Lower car insurance rates

  • Rideshare coverage for Uber and Lyft drivers

Cons

  • Slightly below average J.D. Power customer satisfaction rating

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual bases their car insurance around only paying for what you need. Additionally, it offers several perks and add-ons, including a convenient mobile app, various coverage options, the RightTrack telematics discount, rental reimbursement, vanishing deductibles, and roadside assistance with towing.

Pros

  • Excellent accident forgiveness

  • Superior customer satisfaction and claims satisfaction ratings

Cons

  • Costlier across all measured category

Rating FactorAllstateLiberty Mutual
FitchA+A-
AM BestA+A
Moody’sAa3A2
S&PAA-A
J.D. Power870872

The Best Car Insurance Companies in 2022

RankCompany NameAverage Monthly QuoteInsurify Composite Score
1Clearcover
Best Overall
$13597
2Nationwide
Best for Safe Drivers
$19989
3American Family
Best for Families with Teen Drivers
$23489
4Safeco
Best for Drivers with Poor Credit
$18686
5Farmers
Best for Rideshare Coverage
$23985
6Foremost
Best for Hassle-Free Claims
$15982
7Liberty Mutual
Best for Accident Forgiveness
$24182
8Mercury
Best for Face-to-Face Service
$23281
9Progressive
Best for Senior Drivers
$14780
10Travelers
Best for Young Drivers
$16380
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Liberty Mutual made our top ten 10 list as the best car insurance company for accident forgiveness. Although Allstate is not on the list, it is a leading company for ridesharing coverage for Uber and Lyft drivers, and its rates for young drivers are fairly competitive. In addition, both companies have telematics discount programs for safe drivers.

Compare Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual: Which Is Cheaper?

Allstate is the clear victor, with lower rates in every area evaluated. In particular, in the summary section above, you may have noticed that Liberty Mutual’s average monthly premium is $247, and Allstate’s monthly rate is just $58. That means that, on average, Liberty Mutual’s car insurance policies are over four times costlier than Allstate’s.

The Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in 2022

RankInsurance CompanyAverage Cost Per MonthICS
1USH&C$44Not Rated
2Metromile$63Not Rated
3Direct Auto$64Not Rated
4Travelers$6580
5Kemper$71Not Rated
6Progressive$87Not Rated
7Mile Auto$9185
8National General$9358
9Clearcover$9497
10GAINSCO$94Not Rated
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Allstate’s low prices are one reason it’s a top-five insurance company by market share. In contrast, Liberty Mutual might respond that its target market is mainly concerned with excellent coverage and that pricing is a secondary consideration after robust insurance products, a smooth claims process, and quality customer service.

Compare Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual Car Insurance by Age

Age factors into the price of an auto insurance quote because insurance agents and carriers know that experienced drivers are generally better drivers. As a result, drivers under 25 have the highest car insurance rates. Conversely, policyholders with many years behind the wheel have significantly lower premiums than the youngest drivers.

As you glance at the table below, the trend for both companies is similar. Rates head downward until drivers go beyond their 50s, and then they bump back up as drivers reach retirement and the golden years. At Allstate, those in their 50s received the lowest rates at $50 per month, and at Liberty Mutual, drivers in their 60s scored the best rate at $163 per month.

Age GroupAllstateLiberty Mutual
Teen$124$503
20s$56$261
30s$56$208
40s$53$204
50s$50$182
60s$52$163
70s$58$173
80s$69$177

Compare Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual Car Insurance by Gender

Your gender is another factor that might affect your car insurance premiums. In general, auto insurance premiums between men and women only differ slightly. However, certain insurance companies weigh gender heavily. Statistically, younger men are riskier drivers than women, and insurers charge somewhat higher premiums to offset the added risk.

Allstate bills men five percent more than women, representing a $3 per month difference. And Liberty Mutual has a seven percent discrepancy, with the men paying $17 per month or $204 per year more than the women. Allstate stays below the national average for both men and women, but Liberty Mutual more than triples the national average for both genders.

Which is cheapest for men?

Men should get a quote from Allstate because they beat both Liberty Mutual and the national average. Allstate’s $59 per month is an astounding $197 or $2,364 cheaper than Liberty Mutual. But even compared to the national average of $81 per month, men at Allstate receive an $22 per month or $132 per year price break.

GenderAllstateLiberty MutualNational Average
Men$59$256$81
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Which is cheapest for women?

Allstate is the economical choice for women. Its average monthly quote for women is just $56, making it a whopping $2,196 cheaper than Liberty Mutual’s annual cost. Allstate also slid below the national average, meaning women could put money back into their pocketbooks by year’s end.

GenderAllstateLiberty MutualNational Average
Women$56$239$78
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Compare Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual Car Insurance by Mileage

Usually, the more miles you drive, the more you can expect to pay for car insurance. This is because when auto insurance providers analyze risk, they presume that the more time you spend on the road, the higher probability that you’ll be in a car accident. However, all auto insurance providers don’t assess yearly mileage the same.

Allstate is one of the few auto insurance companies where yearly mileage doesn’t seem to matter, or Allstate may have a number they use regardless of customer estimates. In contrast, the number of annual miles at Liberty Mutual matters quite a bit. At Liberty Mutual, those who drive the most pay $39 per month more than those who drive the least.

Which is cheapest for drivers with high mileage?

If you have a long daily commute or simply love to drive, Allstate’s going to be the better option. Liberty Mutual’s $272 per month is nearly five times more costly than Allstate’s $56 per month. In fact, choosing Allstate could save you $2,592 per year.

Annual MileageAllstateLiberty MutualNational Average
15,000-20,000$56$272$78
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Which is cheapest for drivers with low mileage?

Allstate’s $56 rate is the same regardless of the miles you drive, so it’s still the right selection for a cheaper rate. By contrast, Liberty requires $233 for 5,000 annual miles and $242 for 10,000 miles. So choosing Allstate instead of Liberty Mutual represents savings of $177 or $186 per month, depending on your driving habits.

Annual MileageAllstateLiberty MutualNational Average
5,000$56$233$78
10,000$56$242$78
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Compare Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual Car Insurance by Credit Score

Drivers with excellent credit often qualify for the lowest car insurance rates, while those with mediocre credit have fewer options for budget-friendly insurance. Even if your credit is poor, finding a reasonable price is possible. Simply head over to Insurify to see car insurance rates from multiple companies side-by-side so that you can pick the lowest quote.

Speaking of the lowest quote, you’ll notice that those with better credit earn the best rate when you look at the tables. This fact holds for both companies and the national average. For example, the overall price difference from excellent and poor credit is $18 per month at Allstate but a whopping $110 per month at Liberty Mutual.

Which is cheapest for good credit?

If you have top-notch credit, Allstate deserves a quote. Allstate flies under the national average at both the excellent and good credit levels. On the other hand, Liberty Mutual is over triple the national average with monthly prices of $201 and $214, respectively. Compared to Liberty Mutual, Allstate’s prices translate to a minimum yearly savings of $1,836.

Credit TierAllstateLiberty MutualNational Average
Excellent$48$201$60
Good$53$214$71
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Which is cheapest for bad credit?

If you’re repairing your credit, Allstate is probably the safer alternative. If you have average credit, you’ll save $205 per month when you choose Allstate over Liberty Mutual, and if you have poor credit, you’ll save $245 per month.

Credit TierAllstateLiberty MutualNational Average
Average$54$259$78
Poor$66$311$120
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Compare Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual Car Insurance by Driving Record

When they set your rates, insurance companies rely on your recent driving history, the last three or five years. Therefore, maintaining an accident-free driving record is one of the easiest ways to score an excellent rate with an insurer. However, a driving history with speeding violations, accidents, or DUIs will result in some of the highest rates insurance carriers offer.

It’s probably no secret that finding a reasonable premium can be a challenge with a poor driving record. Happily, companies like Allstate recognize the difficulty and offer relatively affordable rates even with a mishap in your history. Regardless of driver record, Allstate is below, and Liberty Mutual is substantially higher than the national average.

Which is cheapest for good drivers?

Safe driving pays dividends when you choose Allstate. Allstate’s $54 per month is cheaper than the $78 national average and a staggering $186 per month or $2,232 cheaper than Liberty Mutual. Liberty Mutual’s $240 will be unappealing for most drivers even if they heavily value some of the company’s other benefits.

Driver TypeAllstateLiberty MutualNational Average
Clean Record$54$240$78
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Which is cheapest after a speeding ticket?

There’s a correlation between missing your alarm clock and getting a speeding ticket. Fortunately, Allstate arrives on time to offer savings that are cheaper than the national average and over $200 cheaper than Liberty Mutual. So with savings of over $2,400 per year, drivers might zoom right past Liberty Mutual and end up at Allstate.

Driver TypeAllstateLiberty MutualNational Average
Speeding Ticket$70$279$104
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Which is cheapest after an accident?

Although Liberty Mutual has top-of-the-line accident forgiveness, Allstate still manages to offer drivers a far better price. Allstate’s $82 per month outperforms the national average and trounces Liberty Mutual by $207 per month or $2,484 per year. But, of course, every dollar counts even more after an accident, and at Allstate, those dollars go much further.

Driver TypeAllstateLiberty MutualNational Average
Avg. Monthly Quote for Drivers with Accident$82$289$113
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Which is cheapest after a DUI?

No driving infraction shoots up the rates quite like a DUI. For instance, the national average jumps up from $67 per month to $155, a 69 percent increase. But Allstate still finds a way to be inexpensive and skates under the national average with a price of $102 per month. Then again, Liberty Mutual’s $470 per month is over four times the national average.

Driver TypeAllstateLiberty MutualNational Average
DUI$102$470$155
Disclaimer: actual quotes may vary based on the policyholder's unique driver profile.

Compare Car Insurance Quotes Instantly

  • Personalized quotes in 5 minutes or less
  • No signup required

Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual Car Insurance: What discounts does each offer?

DiscountAllstateLiberty Mutual
Anti-Lock Brake
Anti-Theft
Claim-Free
Early Signing
EZ pay plan
FullPay
Good Driver
Good Student
Homeowner
Military
Multi-Car
Multi-Policy
New Car
Online Purchase
Paperless Policy/Allstate eSmart
Preferred Payment/EZ pay plan
RightTrack
Student-Away-At-School
Smart Student
Violation-Free

Our Methodology and How We Compared Allstate and Liberty Mutual

The car insurance quotes provided in Insurify’s insurance company comparison guides are based on the analysis of over 50 thousand insurance quotes from 500 ZIP codes nationwide. Insurify’s data science team performs a comprehensive analysis of factors car insurance providers weigh to calculate rates, including driver demographics, driving record, credit score, desired coverage level, and more to give representative samples.

Insurify’s analysis also incorporates the Insurify Composite Score (ICS) assigned to each insurance provider. The ICS is a proprietary rating calculated by weighing multiple factors that reflect the quality, reliability, and health of an insurance company.

Ratings used to calculate the ICS include Financial Strength Ratings from A.M. Best, Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s, and Fitch; J.D. Power ratings; Consumer Reports customer satisfaction surveys and customer complaints; mobile app reviews; and user-generated company reviews.

With the above insights and ranking methods, Insurify is able to offer car insurance shoppers a window into how insurance providers compare to one another in terms of both cost and quality.

Frequently Asked Questions: Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual

  • After analyzing Allstate vs Liberty Mutual, Allstate insurance is cheaper in every area the data measured. Even after adjusting for demographics and insurance coverage, Allstate is the runaway winner. The average monthly rate at Allstate is $58 compared to $247 at Liberty Mutual.

  • According to the Insurify Composite Score, our internal rating system that evaluates customer satisfaction, reviews, and financial strength ratings, both companies got an equal ranking. Of course, Allstate’s lower price will be the deciding factor for some, but millions of people choose Liberty Mutual every year. So perhaps, the best strategy is to get quotes from both companies.

  • The smartest and easiest way to figure out which insurance provider has the best deal is to use a car insurance quote comparison tool like Insurify. In minutes, you can find rates from these two insurers along with insurance quotes from other top companies such as GEICO, State Farm, and USAA. That way, you can pick the one you think is best.

Compare Car Insurance Quotes Instantly

  • Personalized quotes in 5 minutes or less
  • No signup required
Courtney Roy
Courtney Roy

Insurance Writer

Courtney Roy is a financial and technology writer. He creates content that makes an actionable difference in the lives of his readers by helping them understand matters of personal finance. In addition to years of experience across multiple industries, Courtney has insurance licenses, a real estate license, and a degree in electrical engineering.

Learn More