Hastings Mutual vs Progressive Car Insurance

Compare quotes from 10+ companies in one place Compare Quotes

Personalized quotes in less than 2 minutes.

No signup required

Ratings

Insurify Composite Score Hastings Mutual
VS Progressive

Insurify Composite ScoreProgressive

Compare Quotes

User Ratings

Options	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Rating/Reviews	4 reviews	1,032 reviews

U.S Auto Insurance Shopping Study (2018)

Options	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Overall Satisfaction	--	About average
Policy Offerings	--	About average
Pricing	--	About average
Local Agent	--	About average
Call Center Representative	--	The rest
Insurer Website	--	About average

U.S Auto Insurance Claims Satisfaction Study (2018)

Options	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Overall Satisfaction	--	About average
First Notice of Loss (FNOL)	--	About average
Claim Servicing	--	About average
Estimation Process	--	About average
Repair Process	--	About average
Rental Experience	--	Better than most
Settlement	--	About average

J.D. Power Ratings by Region (out of 1000)

Region	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Southwest	--	812 pt About average
Southeast	--	830 pt About average
Texas	--	815 pt The rest
Central	--	815 pt The rest
Mid-Atlantic	--	835 pt About average
New England	--	826 pt About average
Florida	--	812 pt About average
California	--	800 pt About average
New York	--	816 pt About average
North Central	--	818 pt The rest
Northwest	--	808 pt About average

Mobile App Ratings

Brand	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
iOS	--	317 reviews
Android	--	17,106 reviews

Financial Ratings

Company Name	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
A.M. Best	--	A+
Standard & Poor's	--	A
Fitch	--	A+
Moody's	--	A2

Auto Insurance Quotes

For Married Drivers

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$143	$56
Philadelphia	--	$58
Phoenix	--	$55
Los Angeles	--	$45

For Single Drivers

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$144	$76
Philadelphia	--	$75
Phoenix	--	$70
Los Angeles	--	$77

For Male Drivers

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$138	$63
Philadelphia	--	$64
Phoenix	--	$60
Los Angeles	--	$68

For Female Drivers

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$149	$69
Philadelphia	--	$70
Phoenix	--	$65
Los Angeles	--	$54

For Drivers with a Speeding Ticket

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$266	$82
Philadelphia	--	$83
Phoenix	--	$75
Los Angeles	--	$84

For Drivers with No Speeding Ticket

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$117	$63
Philadelphia	--	$64
Phoenix	--	$60
Los Angeles	--	$56

For Drivers Age Between 18-40

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$155	$75
Philadelphia	--	$74
Phoenix	--	$70
Los Angeles	--	$82

For Drivers Age Between 40-65

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$132	$52
Philadelphia	--	$54
Phoenix	--	$51
Los Angeles	--	$43

For Drivers Age of 65+

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$142	$87
Philadelphia	--	$84
Phoenix	--	$82
Los Angeles	--	$52

For Drivers with Average Credit

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$156	$81
Philadelphia	--	$78
Phoenix	--	$74
Los Angeles	--	$62

For Drivers with Fair Credit

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$154	$78
Philadelphia	--	$77
Phoenix	--	$73
Los Angeles	--	$55

For Drivers with Good Credit

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$139	$46
Philadelphia	--	$50
Phoenix	--	$47
Los Angeles	--	$43

For Drivers with Excellent Credit

City	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Chicago	$126	$59
Philadelphia	--	$62
Phoenix	--	$58
Los Angeles	--	$84

Quotes & Discounts

Discount Type	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Anti-Theft Device Discount	Varies	up to 5%
Good Credit Discount	--	up to 84%
Multiple Vehicle Discount	--	up to 30%
Good Driver Discount	--	up to 26%
Passive Restraint Discount	--	up to 10%
Student Away at School Discount	--	up to 10%
Good Student Discount	--	up to 10%
Multiple Policy Discount	--	up to 10%
E-billing Discount	--	Varies
Paid in full discount	--	Varies
No lapse in coverage discount	--	Varies
Signing documents when you buy online discount	--	Varies
Starting your auto quote online discount	--	Varies
Prepay Discount	--	Varies
Discount Finder	--	Varies
Defensive Driver Discount	--	Varies
Low Mileage Discount	--	Varies
Military Discount	--	Varies
Loyalty Discount	--	Varies
Provider Switch Discount	--	Varies
Home Owner Discount	--	Varies
Preferred payment discount	--	Varies
Youth Driving Discount	--	Varies
Paperless documents discount	--	Varies
Continuous Coverage Discount	--	Varies
teenSMART Discount	--	Varies

Compare Quotes

Payment Methods

Payment Type	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Online Payment
Mobile App Payments	--
Phone Payment	--
Automatic Online Payment	--
Mail Payment	--
Credit Card Payment	--
PayPal	--
Electronic Check	--
Text Payment	--

Feature and Services

Features and Services	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Online account management
Accident forgiveness	--
Loyalty rewards program	--
Mobile app	--
Roadside assistance	--
24/7 service	--

Optional Coverages

Coverage Type	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
Roadside Assistance
Gap Insurance
New Car Replacement Coverage		--
Emergency Assistance Coverage		--
Emergency Lockout Coverage
Pet Coverage
First Aid Reimbursement		--
Accident Forgiveness	--
Rental Reimbursement	--
Glass Coverage	--
Original Equipment Manufacturer Coverage	--
Ridesharing Coverage	--

Insurance by State

Hastings Mutual
Progressive
Both

Uber and Lyft driver insurance:

Hastings Mutual
Progressive
Both

SR‌-22 Insurance by State

Hastings Mutual
Progressive
Both

Compare Insurance Products

Product	Hastings Mutual	Progressive
ATV Insurance	--
Boat Insurance	--
Business Insurance	--
Car Insurance
Cell Phone Insurance	--
Classic Car Insurance	--
Commercial Insurance	--
Condo Insurance	--
Flood Insurance	--
Golf Cart Insurance	--
Health Insurance	--
Home Insurance	--
Homeshare Insurance	--
Identity Theft Insurance	--
Life Insurance	--
Mobile Home Insurance	--
Motorcycle Insurance	--
Personal Watercraft Insurance	--
Pet Insurance	--
RV Insurance	--
Renters Insurance	--
Segway Insurance	--
Snowmobile insurance	--
Travel Insurance	--
Umbrella Insurance	--
Wedding and Event Insurance	--