insurify
  • Compare Quotes

    Start Search

  • Menu
    • Car Insurance
    • Home Insurance
    • Virtual Agent
    • About
    • Blog
  • Car Insurance Home Insurance Virtual Agent About Blog
  • Start Saving
insurify
insurify
  • Start saving now

Allstate vs Esurance Car Insurance

Compare quotes from 10+ companies in one place Compare Quotes

  Personalized quotes in less than 2 minutes.

  No signup required

Ratings

Insurify Composite Score Allstate
VS Esurance
What's this?
Insurify Composite ScoreEsurance
What's this?
Compare Quotes
User Ratings
Options Allstate Esurance
Rating/Reviews
Full Star Full Star Half Star Empty Star Empty Star
1,131 reviews
Full Star Full Star Full Star Half Star Empty Star
4,712 reviews
U.S Auto Insurance Shopping Study (2018)
Options Allstate Esurance
Overall Satisfaction The rest About average
Policy Offerings The rest About average
Pricing The rest About average
Local Agent About average --
Call Center Representative About average Among the best
Insurer Website The rest About average
U.S Auto Insurance Claims Satisfaction Study (2018)
Options Allstate Esurance
Overall Satisfaction About average About average
First Notice of Loss (FNOL) About average About average
Claim Servicing About average About average
Estimation Process Better than most About average
Repair Process Better than most The rest
Rental Experience About average About average
Settlement About average About average
J.D. Power Ratings by Region (out of 1000)
Region Allstate Esurance
Southwest
815 pt
About average
--
Southeast
830 pt
About average
--
Texas
835 pt
Better than most
--
Central
822 pt
About average
--
Mid-Atlantic
837 pt
About average
--
New England
834 pt
Better than most
--
Florida
837 pt
Better than most
826 pt
About average
California
820 pt
About average
818 pt
About average
New York
824 pt
About average
--
North Central
823 pt
About average
799 pt
The rest
Northwest
798 pt
The rest
--
Mobile App Ratings
Brand Allstate Esurance
iOS
Full Star Full Star Full Star Full Star Half Star
56,800 reviews
Full Star Full Star Full Star Half Star Empty Star
108 reviews
Android
Full Star Full Star Full Star Full Star Half Star
12,515 reviews
Full Star Full Star Full Star Full Star Half Star
4,165 reviews
Financial Ratings
Company Name Allstate Esurance
A.M. Best A+ A+
Standard & Poor's AA- --
Fitch A+ --
Moody's Aa3 --

Auto Insurance Quotes

For Married Drivers

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $36 $84
Chicago $111 $76
Philadelphia $133 $104
Phoenix $105 $74
Los Angeles $116 $66

For Single Drivers

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $41 $80
Chicago $128 $79
Philadelphia $135 $108
Phoenix $128 $81
Los Angeles $255 $106

For Male Drivers

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $39 $84
Chicago $123 $80
Philadelphia $129 $104
Phoenix $129 $80
Los Angeles $252 $104

For Female Drivers

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $39 $80
Chicago $115 $74
Philadelphia $139 $107
Phoenix $104 $75
Los Angeles $119 $68

For Drivers with a Speeding Ticket

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $43 $95
Chicago $175 $102
Philadelphia $143 $127
Phoenix $162 $94
Los Angeles $341 $130

For Drivers with No Speeding Ticket

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $38 $79
Chicago $107 $72
Philadelphia $132 $103
Phoenix $107 $74
Los Angeles $152 $77

For Drivers Age Between 18-40

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $41 $78
Chicago $129 $77
Philadelphia $130 $107
Phoenix $133 $78
Los Angeles $290 $118

For Drivers Age Between 40-65

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $36 $78
Chicago $102 $72
Philadelphia $121 $98
Phoenix $94 $71
Los Angeles $104 $62

For Drivers Age of 65+

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $41 $112
Chicago $145 $101
Philadelphia $193 $130
Phoenix $140 $101
Los Angeles $100 $56

For Drivers with Average Credit

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $40 $82
Chicago $121 $80
Philadelphia $149 $113
Phoenix $113 $79
Los Angeles $153 $78

For Drivers with Fair Credit

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $37 $95
Chicago $124 $83
Philadelphia $153 $125
Phoenix $117 $82
Los Angeles $132 $72

For Drivers with Good Credit

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $38 $79
Chicago $106 $73
Philadelphia $120 $100
Phoenix $103 $74
Los Angeles $129 $70

For Drivers with Excellent Credit

City Allstate Esurance
Austin $40 $73
Chicago $124 $72
Philadelphia $114 $85
Phoenix $133 $75
Los Angeles $327 $124

Quotes & Discounts

Discount Type Allstate Esurance
teenSMART Discount
up to 35%
--
Accident Forgiveness
up to 30%
--
Defensive Driver Discount
up to 20%
up to 10%
New Car Discount
up to 15%
--
Multiple Vehicle Discount
up to 10%
up to 5%
Passive Restraint Discount
up to 10%
up to 33%
Prepay Discount
up to 10%
up to 10%
Paid in full discount
up to 10%
up to 10%
Early Quote Discount
up to 10%
--
Multiple Policy Discount
up to 10%
up to 15%
Low Mileage Discount
up to 10%
--
Good Student Discount
up to 10%
up to 10%
Good Driver Discount
up to 10%
up to 40%
Farm Vehicle Discount
up to 10%
--
EV/Hybrid Discount
up to 10%
--
Anti-lock Brake Discount
up to 10%
up to 5%
E-billing Discount
up to 10%
--
Anti-Theft Device Discount
up to 10%
up to 25%
Preferred payment discount
up to 5%
--
Good Payer Discount
up to 5%
--
Student Away at School Discount
up to 5%
--
Senior Adult Discount
up to 5%
--
Paperless documents discount
Varies
--
Driving training discount
Varies
--
Deductible discount
Varies
--
Family Discount
Varies
--
Utility Vehicle Discount
Varies
--
Accident Free Discount
--
up to 25%
Alumni Discount
--
up to 15%
Driving Habits Discount
--
up to 5%
Organization Discount
--
up to 5%
Starting your auto quote online discount
--
up to 5%
Roadside Assistance Discount
--
up to 5%
Provider Switch Discount
--
up to 5%
Home Owner Discount
--
Varies
Signing documents when you buy online discount
--
Varies
Compare Quotes

Payment Methods

Payment Type Allstate Esurance
Automatic Online Payment Complete Tick
--
Debit Card Payments Complete Tick
--
Electronic Check Complete Tick
--
Online Payment Complete Tick
--
Prepayment Complete Tick
--
Mail Payment Complete Tick
--
Phone Payment Complete Tick
--
Person 2 Person Payment Complete Tick
--
Bank Payment/Direct Deposit Complete Tick
--
Credit Card Payment Complete Tick
--
Mobile App Payments Complete Tick Complete Tick

Feature and Services

Features and Services Allstate Esurance
Roadside assistance Complete Tick Complete Tick
Mobile app Complete Tick Complete Tick
24/7 service Complete Tick Complete Tick
Accident forgiveness Complete Tick
--
Online account management Complete Tick Complete Tick
Loyalty rewards program Complete Tick
--
Enhanced towing & substitute coverage Complete Tick
--
Policy bundling discounts
--
Complete Tick

Optional Coverages

Coverage Type Allstate Esurance
No Fault Coverage Complete Tick
--
Mechanical Breakdown Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
Loss of Use Coverage Complete Tick Complete Tick
New Car Replacement Coverage Complete Tick
--
Rental Reimbursement Complete Tick Complete Tick
Roadside Assistance Complete Tick Complete Tick
Sound System Coverage Complete Tick
--
Umbrella Policy Complete Tick
--
Antique or Collector Car Insurance Complete Tick
--
Ridesharing Coverage Complete Tick
--
Preferred Repair Services Complete Tick
--
Accidental Death, Dismemberment, Disability Complete Tick
--
Emergency Lockout Coverage Complete Tick
--
Accident Forgiveness Complete Tick
--
Incident Forgiveness
--
Complete Tick
Emergency Assistance Coverage
--
Complete Tick
Gap Insurance
--
Complete Tick
Original Equipment Manufacturer Coverage
--
Complete Tick

Insurance by State

  • Car Insurance
  • Life Insurance
  • Motorcycle Insurance
  • Renters Insurance
  • Home / Condo Insurance
  • RV Insurance
  • Umbrella Insurance
  • Allstate
  • Esurance
  • Both

Uber and Lyft driver insurance:

  • Allstate
  • Esurance
  • Both

SR‌-22 Insurance by State

  • Allstate
  • Esurance
  • Both

Compare Insurance Products

Product Allstate Esurance
  ATV Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Boat Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Business Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Car Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Cell Phone Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Classic Car Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Commercial Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Condo Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Flood Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Health Insurance
--
Complete Tick
  Home Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Life Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Motorcycle Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Pet Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  RV Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Renters Insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Snowmobile insurance Complete Tick Complete Tick
  Umbrella Insurance
--
Complete Tick

Popular Comparisons

  • Allstate vs Encompass
  • Allstate vs NJ Manufacturers
  • Allstate vs State Farm
  • Esurance vs GEICO
  • Esurance vs Mercury
  • Esurance vs USAA

User Reviews

  • Allstate Reviews
  • Esurance Reviews
★ ★★ ★★
2.8
1,131 user reviews
5 Stars
25% Complete
25%
4 Stars
14% Complete
14%
3 Stars
7% Complete
7%
2 Stars
7% Complete
7%
1 Star
48% Complete
48%
Write a Review
Most Positive Review
★ ★★ ★★
By James
December 11, 2017

All of the hard work you guys have done to try to find me the cheapest rate and always staying in contact with me to make sure everything is going okay I love this they really are kindness towards their future customers

Most Critical Review
★ ★★ ★★
By Jerry
December 1, 2017

The last three policy periods Allstate has increased my premiums. I have no accidents, no tickets, no DUI's, no nothing and yet you continue to punishment me by raising my rates. Last period I had to raise my deductible from 500 to 750 just so I could continue to pay my premiums. I am VERY, VERY, VERY UNHAPPY with Allstate. Allstate gets a ZERO rating from me.

★ ★★ ★★
3.8
4,712 user reviews
5 Stars
38% Complete
38%
4 Stars
7% Complete
7%
3 Stars
2% Complete
2%
2 Stars
18% Complete
18%
1 Star
36% Complete
36%
Write a Review
Most Positive Review
Affordable
★ ★★ ★★
By Insurify User
September 1, 2014

Esurance is not only affordable but very efficient as well. They took care of my claim very quickly and without any hassle. Everyone was pleasant and on top their work. As a matter of fact I was overwhelmed with the attention on got. The check arrived at the body shop before my car was there! I have recommended esurance to all my friends and family.

Most Critical Review
★ ★★ ★★
By Shane
December 3, 2017

Poor billing procedures or information changes to billing procedures has messed me up significantly causing me financial burdens and coverage problems beyond comprehension. Was uninsured without knowledge, dropped coverage for no fault of my own. Then offered a chance to reinstate and once again no letter with attached statement for billing. Only thing received was a letter of debt collection for $49.00. now I'm trying to fix your mistake and it's costing me lots of time which info not have and hundreds if not thousands of $.

insurify

Don't miss saving $400 on your car insurance

Compare Quotes

insurify Blog

10 Best & Worst Sites to Compare Car Insurance Quotes 10 Best Auto Insurance Companies for Uber and Lyft Drivers 10 Best Car Insurance Companies of 2019 10 Best & Worst Sites to Compare Home Insurance Quotes The Ultimate Guide to SR-22 Car Insurance
About Blog Careers Press Reviews Privacy Policy Terms & Conditions Help

Top Car Insurance Companies

21st Century Amica Dairyland Esurance
Farmers The General The Hartford Liberty Mutual
Mercury MetLife Nationwide Plymouth Rock
Safeco Travelers USAA All companies

Compare Car Insurance Companies

GEICO vs NJ Manufacturers
Farm Bureau Financial Services vs USAA
GEICO vs Root
AAA vs Ameriprise
GEICO vs Travelers
GEICO vs USAA
State Farm vs Travelers
Auto-Owners vs State Farm

Car Insurance By City

Atlanta, GA Charleston, SC Charlotte, NC Chicago, IL Columbus, OH Dallas, TX Denver, CO Houston, TX Jacksonville, FL Las Vegas, NV Los Angeles, CA Memphis, TN Miami, FL Orlando, FL Philadelphia, PA Phoenix, AZ San Antonio, TX San Diego, CA Tampa, FL

Car Insurance By State

AK AL AR AZ CA CO CT DC DE FL GA HI IA ID IL IN KS KY LA MA MD ME MI MN MO MS MT NC ND NE NH NJ NM NV NY OH OK OR PA RI SC SD TN TX UT VA VT WA WI WV WY

© 2013-2019 Insurify, Inc. All rights reserved. Ensurify Insurance Agency is a licensed insurance agency in 50 states.