Don’t let its small size fool you. The “Garden State” is big on a lot of things. Rock Star Bruce Springsteen, the light bulb, and the streets of Monopoly all hailed from here. The state is also known for having the most people per square foot of space- a situation ripe for fender benders and other kinds of automobile accidents.

Fortunately, the state has worked to make meeting minimum insurance requirements more accessible to everyone. Going online to find the best and cheapest car insurance quotes, no matter your driver profile, is a cinch.

Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Jersey

Here are the cheapest insurance companies in New Jersey for the following user profile: a single, 30-year-old male with a clean driving record who drives a 2012 Honda Accord and pays a $1,000 deductible for the state’s minimum liability insurance. We averaged rates for the twenty most populous cities in New Jersey.

Insurance CompanyQuote
Progressive$86/month
Liberty Mutual$154/month
Travelers$180/month
Allstate$220/month
State Farm$226/month

Best Car Insurance Quotes in New Jersey

The Insurify Composite Score is calculated by analyzing multiple factors that indicate the quality, reliability, and health of an insurance company. Inputs to the score include financial strength ratings from A.M. Best, Standard & Poor’s, Moody’s, and Fitch; J.D. Power ratings; Consumer Reports customer satisfaction surveys; mobile app reviews; and user-generated company reviews. The following are the top-rated companies that offer car insurance in New Jersey. For the complete list, see Insurify’s best car insurance companies.

Insurance CompanyComposite ScoreQuotes
American Family88$277/month
Allstate86$220/month
State Farm83$226/month
Travelers81$180/month
Liberty Mutual80$154/month
Progressive78$86/month

Most Popular Car Insurance Companies in New Jersey

The state of New Jersey boasts over 50 seaside resort towns. Picking the most popular is definitely open to interpretation.

In the case of car insurance companies, we base popularity on those providers that generate the most business across the Garden State.

According to the Insurance Information Institute (III), these are the most popular car insurance providers in New Jersey by market share:

Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Jersey by City

Shopping and dining is big in New Jersey. In fact, the state has the most shopping malls in America (second only to Texas).

If you have a lot of shopping to do, you’ll appreciate saving those extra few dollars at the end of every month on car insurance with these companies. 

CityInsurance CompanyQuote
NewarkProgressive$138/month
Jersey CityProgressive$109/month
PatersonProgressive$110/month
ElizabethProgressive$131/month
EdisonProgressive$86/month

Cheapest Car Insurance Quotes in New Jersey by Profile

Here are the cheapest insurance companies in New Jersey based on averaged sample rates for four driver profiles that included varied gender, age, driving history, credit, marital status, prior insurance, higher education, employment, and military service

Cheap Car Insurance Quotes for Good Drivers

Good driving doesn’t go unrewarded in New Jersey. There’s no such thing as cookie-cutter discounts for clean driving records. No two insurance companies are going to reward you the same way, so get in there and make sure you are getting what you deserve! 

Insurance CompanyQuote
Progressive$86/month
Liberty Mutual$154/month
Travelers$180/month
Allstate$220/month
State Farm$226/month

Cheap Car Insurance Quotes for High-Risk Drivers

Sure, you have to pay for your mistakes, but just how much is reasonable? For how long? Even drivers who have had accidents, have a DUI on their record or are otherwise classified as high-risk have the right to seek out lower car insurance rates. And they’ll find them!

Cheap Car Insurance for Drivers with DUI in New Jersey

Insurance CompanyQuotes
New Jersey Manufacturers$36/month
Progressive
$84/month
GEICO
$90/month

Cheap Car Insurance for Drivers with an At-Fault Accident in New Jersey

Insurance CompanyQuotes
New Jersey Manufacturers
$30/month
GEICO
$64/month
Amica
$77/month

Cheap Car Insurance for Speeding Drivers in New Jersey

Insurance CompanyQuotes
New Jersey Manufacturers
$36/month
GEICO
$47/month
Plymouth Rock
$75/month

Cheap Car Insurance Quotes for Young Drivers Under 40

If that rite of passage is draining your bank account, you should know that young drivers can get breaks on their motorist coverage, too. Certainly, it makes sense that taking on the risks associated with young drivers means more money from you. But there are ways a young driver can mitigate those risks by finding insurance discounts created just for them. Safe driving and good student discounts just a few ways that being a young driver, or having one on your auto policy, can let you make peace with your pocketbook and keep insurance premiums low.

Insurance CompaniesQuotes
Tennessee Farmers$31/month
GEICO$44/month
Amica$60/month
Plymouth Rock$64/month
Progressive$68/month

New Jersey State Insurance Laws

Car insurance is mandatory in New Jersey.

Unlike other states, however, New Jersey-licensed insurance producers must provide drivers with the choice of purchasing two different types of policies to meet those minimum coverage levels.

State Minimum Car Insurance Coverage in New Jersey

The state minimum insurance you need to legally drive in the state is within the Basic Policy. The Standard Policy includes the minimum and then some. The table below shows you both the differences between the policy types, coverage options, and the minimum required liability coverage

Basic Policy Details

A basic policy costs less than the standard policy, but in turn, provides less coverage. The basic policy includes:

Bodily injury liability: Not included in the basic policy. However, $10,000 coverage for all persons, per accident is an add-on that is available to purchase from any insurer.

Property damage liability: $5,000 per accident.

Personal Injury Protection: $15,000 per person, per accident. Up to $250,000 (depending on injury).

Collision coverage and Comprehensive coverage: Not included in the basic policy, but available as an option from some insurers.

Standard Policy Details

Bodily injury liability: As low as $15,000 per person, $30,000 per accident. As high as $250,000 per person, $500,000 per accident.

Property damage liability: As low as $5,000 per accident. As high as $100,000 or more.

Personal Injury Protection: $15,000 per person, per accident; up to $250,000 for certain injuries.

Collision coverage and Comprehensive coverage: Not included in the basic policy, but available as an option from any insurer.

Distracted Driving Laws in New Jersey

Distracted driving was cited as a major contributing factor in nearly 800,000 motor vehicle crashes in the state from 2012-2016. It’s no wonder then, that New Jersey is tough when it comes to hands-free device driving rules. Here are the penalties for texting, talking, or scrolling on a device while driving: 

  • First offense: $200 to $400
  • Second offense: $400 to $600
  • Third and subsequent offenses: Up to $800, three points on your license and a possible 90-day suspension of your license.

Obtaining a Driver’s License in New Jersey

Before you head out to get your permit or license in New Jersey, know that this state wants to make extra sure of who you are. New Jersey requires you to have a total of “6 Points of ID,” including: 

Immigration Status and Driving Laws in New Jersey

Although legislation is under review that would allow undocumented immigrants the ability to legally drive, currently it is illegal for any undocumented immigrant to drive in New Jersey.

Providing false documentation in an attempt to obtain a license could get you in a lot of trouble.

New Jersey’s strict policy for submitting identification documents includes running all documents

How to See Your New Jersey Driver History Abstract

Just how do insurers know so much about your driving record? Or better yet, what exactly is on your record? Sometimes online quoting systems allow you to enter details of your driving record in to give you a preliminary quote.

In New Jersey, you can get this information by requesting your Driver History Abstract online or in person. Details on ordering your Driver History Abstract and how to read it can be found here.

New Jersey Auto Insurance FAQs 

Can undocumented immigrants get a New Jersey driver’s license?

No. Although some states do offer ways for undocumented immigrants to drive legally, New Jersey does not issue licenses to anyone who cannot pass the state’s 6 Points of ID verification.

How do I register a classic car in New Jersey?

If your car is at least twenty-five (25) years old, you can apply for “historic” registration. It must be covered by the minimum automobile insurance coverage, owned as a collector’s item, and used solely for exhibition or educational purposes.

How old do you have to be to drive in New Jersey?

New Jersey has a multi-stage licensing process that allows drivers to gain a permit at age 16 and unrestricted driving privileges at age 18.

Do the bigger insurance companies like AAA and State Farm always have the cheapest rates in New Jersey?

The question isn’t do they have the cheapest rates—but do they have the cheapest rates for you. Insurance shopping is a very personalized experience today. One company may specialize in at-risk drivers, while others serve up unique programs to reward good driving records or help young drivers keep rates reasonable. Regardless of who you are, policyholders can save by comparing quotes online with Insurify.

New Jersey DMV Information

If you are new to the state and want to get a new license and/or register your vehicle, you’ll have to visit a New Jersey Motor Vehicle Commission (NJMVC). 

You can find a location closest to you here (type “license” or “registration” in the search box). Make sure you’ve already secured insurance policies before you proceed to register your vehicle(s).

Registering Your Vehicle

New vehicle registration is taken care of by the car dealership (as long as the car was purchased from a New Jersey dealership). For all other vehicles (including transferring a vehicle into New Jersey), you’ll need to bring at least the following paperwork to the NJMVC:

  • Title
  • Driver’s license or another ID card (See 6 Points of ID)
  • New Jersey insurance card or company name and policy number

See their vehicle registration page for more information on New Jersey registration requirements.

Online Services 

Although first time licensing and registration must be done in-person, the NJMVC does offer renewals and additional driving-related services online, including:

  • Change of address
  • License and registration duplicates
  • Standard license renewals
  • Vehicle registration renewals
  • Organ donor registration
  • Driver History Abstract
  • Special plates
  • Other services

See a complete list of NJMVC online services here.

Conclusion

New Jersey is known for a lot, from saltwater taffy to boardwalks to beach getaways. And now you know a lot more about finding the best insurance in this state. 

You deserve to find and compare the best and cheapest car insurance deals for you. Don’t just rely on the insurance plan your neighbor has, even if they’re covered by old standbys like AAA, Allstate, Plymouth Rock, NJ Manufacturers, and State Farm.

Instead, use your own noggin and Internet connection to go online and get a faster, reliable, more convenient car insurance quote that may save you big bucks this year with Insurify.

How sweet is that?! 

Score savings on car insurance with Insurify

Compare Quotes

Jeannette Wisniewski is a technology writer whose passion is encouraging people to engage with technology by making it more understandable and more interesting. Though she enjoys writing business copy for a wide range of subjects, she is most inspired by emerging tech and its applications. She is a graduate of San Jose State University, a Georgia Peach at heart, and happy to call Boise, ID home.