Is State Farm a Good Insurance Company? Reviews From Over 21,491 Customers

State Farm customers rate it a 4.2 out of 5. Positive reviews focus on customer service, while less positive reviews mention issues with policy transparency.

Secure. Free. Easy-to-use.
4.7 / 518K reviews
Photo of an Insurify author
Writer: Katie PowersLicensed P&C Agent, Senior Insurance Editor

Qualifications:
  • Licensed auto and home insurance agent

  • 4+ years experience in insurance and personal finance editing

  • NPN: 20564519


Katie uses her knowledge and expertise as a licensed property and casualty agent in Massachusetts to help readers understand the complexities of insurance shopping.

MacKenzie Korris
Editor: MacKenzie KorrisLicensed P&C Agent, Senior Insurance Copy Editor

Qualifications:
  • Licensed property and casualty insurance agent

  • 10+ years editing experience

  • NPN: 21630969


MacKenzie Korris is an insurance copy editor with a producer’s license for property and casualty insurance in Missouri.

Updated

Why you can trust Insurify: Comparing accurate insurance quotes should never put you at risk of spam. We earn an agent commission only if you buy a policy based on our quotes. Our editorial team follows a rigorous set of editorial standards and operates independently from our insurance partners. Learn more.

State Farm Insurance: Rated 4.2 out of 5 by customers

Category
Average Score
Overall experience rating4.2
Customer service4.4
Value3.9
Claims handling4.2
Coverage options4.2
Discounts4.0
Policy transparency4.0
Policy flexibility4.1
Quick Facts
  • State Farm overall user rating: 4.2 out of 5

  • Insurify Quality (IQ) Score for State Farm: 9.3 out of 10

  • NAIC complaint index: 0.85 (Below average)

  • Average monthly full-coverage premium from State Farm: $103

Our take on State Farm insurance

Insurify gives State Farm a quality score of 9.3 out of 10. Overall, State Farm customer reviews are largely positive, but many Insurify customers with State Farm policies have mixed feelings about the insurer.

Customers who are happy with State Farm spotlight long-lasting relationships with local agents, quick response times, and satisfaction with the quality of coverage. But some negative reviews highlight disappointment with discount savings, slow claims handling, and premium increases at renewal.

Insurify’s customers with State Farm policies give the company an overall customer service rating of 4.4 out of 5.

State Farm customer service reviews: Rated 4.4 out of 5

State Farm customers rate the company 4.4 out of 5 for customer service. Customers who left positive reviews often appreciate their established relationships with knowledgeable and easy-to-work-with local agents. Unsatisfied customers cite frustration with slow follow-up and long wait times.

You can read real reviews from satisfied and unsatisfied State Farm customers below.

View State Farm customer service reviewsexpand/collapse
Mark
Verified Review
Looking
Great service, just high rates.
Cathy
Verified Review
Loyal to State Farm, but the high cost is forcing me to look elsewhere
Excellent customer service. My only concern is the high cost.
Sharon
Verified Review
I've been covered by them since I was 16—that's 60+ years. They’ve been there for me whether it’s a question, a claim, or just checking in to make sure my needs are met.
I've been covered by them since I was 16—that's 60+ years. They’ve been there for me whether it’s a question, a claim, or just checking in to make sure my needs are met.
Matthew
Verified Review
Good Customer Service
The local office was very helpful.
Carol
Verified Review
Great auto insurance
Friendly service, and they found what was right for me at a great price.
Sandra
Verified Review
I Recommend State Farm for Satisfying Service
Professional and excellent customer service overall.
Terrence
Verified Review
Love This State Farm Office
Great agency office. She was extremely helpful in getting us a new policy in Florida. I would highly recommend them.
Jennifer
Verified Review
They Go Above and Beyond
I like the rate and the perks. I also like how the office staff is always helpful.
Dale
Verified Review
I asked if there was a way to lower our auto insurance. They said they would get back to us, but they never did.
I asked if there was a way to lower our auto insurance. They said they would get back to us, but they never did.
Lauren
Verified Review
Some of the people don’t seem to have a clue what’s going on. I ask a direct question and never get an answer. They just don’t know or don’t care. Home insurance is OK, I guess. Because we’re in Bay Minette and within a 40-mile radius of the coast, we pay the same as having a beach house. The deductible on my home is around $5,000 to $5,400. They usually don’t cover what I need. For 3 autos and a house, it’s around $6,000 a year. I’m 77 years old, and they never have any suggestions on how to lower my insurance. By the way, I’ve had insurance with State Farm for around 46 to 50 years and get a discount because I’ve been with the two agents for 25 years. Nothing for senior citizens at State Farm.
Some of the people don’t seem to have a clue what’s going on. I ask a direct question and never get an answer. They just don’t know or don’t care. Home insurance is OK, I guess. Because we’re in Bay Minette and within a 40-mile radius of the coast, we pay the same as having a beach house. The deductible on my home is around $5,000 to $5,400. They usually don’t cover what I need. For 3 autos and a house, it’s around $6,000 a year. I’m 77 years old, and they never have any suggestions on how to lower my insurance. By the way, I’ve had insurance with State Farm for around 46 to 50 years and get a discount because I’ve been with the two agents for 25 years. Nothing for senior citizens at State Farm.
Deborah
Verified Review
Tow truck service was really poor
When I needed towing service three times this year, it took over 3 to 4.5 hours to get a tow truck driver through my insurance, so I ended up paying for the tow myself.
Vicki
Verified Review
Needs to Be Addressed
They got my address wrong and then acted like it was my fault.
Alicia
Verified Review
A Positive Friend
I’ve known my current insurance agent for years. Peggy has supported me with coaching for the YMCA, Carroll band fundraising, and my older two sons’ football programs.
Gina
Verified Review
I’ve been with them for years. I can’t view my bill online, and I can’t see my proof of insurance card online either. They tell me I don’t need one because when my tag is run it will show proof, but if I travel and I’m asked for it, then I don’t have it and can’t access it. I also think I’m paying too much for two vehicles. I just paid my bill for this month, and I’m going to find other insurance soon. Just disappointed.
I’ve been with them for years. I can’t view my bill online, and I can’t see my proof of insurance card online either. They tell me I don’t need one because when my tag is run it will show proof, but if I travel and I’m asked for it, then I don’t have it and can’t access it. I also think I’m paying too much for two vehicles. I just paid my bill for this month, and I’m going to find other insurance soon. Just disappointed.
Kevin
Verified Review
Ending My Relationship With State Farm
The local agency doesn’t return calls. The deductible options shown in the policy selection forms aren’t actually available. I’ve been with State Farm for 15 years and just got quotes from four other companies that are substantially less for equivalent coverage. I’ll be terminating my coverage with State Farm—it’s just not worth it.
Kern
Verified Review
Unhappy Customer
The little transponder (or whatever it is) that goes on the windshield feels like nothing but a “gotcha.” There’s no opportunity to explain anything, and it even registers normal maneuvers in Atlanta traffic as negatives. Also, I got a $20 rate increase at 6 months without an explanation, and I had to take an additional safe driver course (even though I already had one on file) to get a $10 reduction. I’ve never had a chargeable accident, never a DUI, and my last ticket was 20+ years ago. I feel like I’m being charged more because I’m 83, which seems improper in the first place. I’m searching for another provider who deals honestly like SF did years ago. No problems with my agency—they’re good—just the company.

State Farm customer service reviews vs. AAA and Allstate

State Farm earns a customer service rating of 4.4 out of 5, which outpaces Allstate but is in line with AAA. Insurify’s customers give a rating of 4.0 to Allstate and 4.5 to AAA.

Allstate customers give it lower satisfaction ratings than State Farm for customer service, with reviews mentioning feeling unsupported during complicated insurance issues. AAA also earns higher ratings than Allstate, with customers praising stable, dependable service.

Below, you can see how real Insurify customers rate these companies for customer service.

Company
Average Score
State Farm4.4
AAA4.5
Allstate4.0

State Farm discounts reviews: Rated 4.0 out of 5

State Farm has a discount rating of 4.0 out of 5 from Insurify’s customers with coverage from the insurer. Positive reviews mentioning discounts touch on State Farm’s bundling opportunities and occasional promotional savings. 

But many customers describe dissatisfaction with their actual discount savings, citing unclear terms.

Here are reviews from real State Farm customers about discounts. Read about common positive and negative experiences.

View State Farm customer reviews for discountsexpand/collapse
Robert
Verified Review
Like a Good Neighbor
If you're willing, Drive Safe & Save will reduce your premiums.
Dan
Verified Review
I’m happy with the discounts and the service
I would refer my insurance company to a friend.
Sophie
Verified Review
Great experience. I have been a long time customer.
Get all the discounts you can for any insurance you have. It can make a big difference.
Lloyd
Verified Review
Payment Discount
I called to see if I could get a discount, and I was very happy with the discount I received.
Glynn
Verified Review
Glynn’s Review
It's okay. I do like the safe driving profile they have.
David
Verified Review
Big Dave’s Review
Great coverage and it's nice how State Farm provides linking coverage across vehicles so you do not overpay for the same coverage across multiple vehicles. If you pay for certain coverage on one vehicle, it is applied to all vehicles, which saves quite a bit of money.
Annamaria
Verified Review
Good, but need discounts for elderly
Yes, I will tell my friends and family members about State Farm.
Michael
Verified Review
Excellent
Love being able to get a bundle price with them, also rental assistance and roadside assistance.
Allan
Verified Review
State Farm hoax
You need the Drive Safe & Save app so that when you’re not driving, it doesn’t record trips and you still get the discount. Otherwise, it feels like we end up paying more even though we’re driving less.
Lauren
Verified Review
Fed Up With State Farm
Go with anyone besides State Farm! I’ve been with the same agents for 46 years, and my rate goes up every year. I get a discount because I’ve been with them for over 25 years, but I’ve actually been with them for almost twice that.
Khalid
Verified Review
Overall is good, but I didn’t get any discounts despite having a good driving record.
It’s expensive.
Dan
Verified Review
No Discount
My rates keep going up, even though I haven’t had any claims in over 10 years.
Brij
Verified Review
You show a senior discount, but there is none. Good driver discount—there is none. Low mileage.
Your advertising doesn’t match what’s actually offered.
Jack
Verified Review
Too Much
My insurance keeps going up even though I’m enrolled in Drive Safe. I think I pay too much, and I’m considering shopping around for better rates.
Brittany
Verified Review
I Will Never Refer Them to Anyone Looking for a New Company Right Now
The rates are high, and it feels like nothing is really covered. There’s no accident forgiveness.
Lewis
Verified Review
Sloppy Service
They were supposed to send me a beacon, but I never got it. Now they want to raise my rates. I’m looking for new insurance and I don’t recommend them.

State Farm discounts reviews vs. AAA and Allstate

Insurify’s customers with coverage from State Farm give the company a discount availability rating of 4.0 out of 5, ranking similarly to Allstate but behind AAA. Allstate earns a discount rating of 3.9 out of 5, and AAA earns a rating of 4.5 out of 5.

State Farm and Allstate have similar ratings for discount availability, with customers appreciating the bundling and loyalty discounts offered by both. AAA ranks higher than State Farm and Allstate, with customers mentioning discounts that apply for a long time and keep costs reasonable.

See how Insurify’s customers rank State Farm, Allstate, and AAA for discount availability.

Company
Average Score
State Farm4.0
AAA4.5
Allstate3.9

State Farm claims handling reviews: Rated 4.2 out of 5

State Farm has a claims handling rating of 4.2 out of 5. Customers who had good experiences describe a straightforward claims process, fast resolutions, and supportive adjusters. But other State Farm customers highlight long delays and dissatisfaction over claim denials or low settlements.

Below, you can read real claims handling reviews from Insurify’s customers with State Farm policies.

View State Farm customer reviews for claims handlingexpand/collapse
Thomas
Verified Review
Good Neighbor Performance
State Farm handled my claim in a very satisfactory manner. Repairs were completed in a timely manner. The auto rental was handled entirely by State Farm. I couldn’t have expected more!
Clayton
Verified Review
My claim was handled quickly and fairly. My only question was why I didn’t have rental coverage on my policy. I’ve owned my car since I bought it new in 2018 and have always kept full coverage on it. I guess my first mistake was thinking I had rental coverage!
My claim was handled quickly and fairly. My only question was why I didn’t have rental coverage on my policy. I’ve owned my car since I bought it new in 2018 and have always kept full coverage on it. I guess my first mistake was thinking I had rental coverage!
Bruce
Verified Review
Accessible, Reliable, Trustworthy
We have bundled auto and home insurance. Claims for both have been covered promptly, and we are totally satisfied.
Curtiss
Verified Review
My Review
I like most things about my insurance. They handled an accident I had just as I expected. The only problem I have is that I think the policy is a little expensive, and they don’t offer a policy where I can be insured in any car I drive.
Carroll
Verified Review
Claim Service Was Good
Overall, good.
Jesse
Verified Review
Vaughn
Expect it to go up every year. Excellent claim service.
Kenny
Verified Review
Loyalty Doesn’t Seem to Count for Much
I’ve been with them for decades, and I thought that might mean something after an at-fault accident where no one was injured and my car was repaired in about a week. The other person involved also had State Farm, but that—and my loyalty—didn’t seem to count for much, because my insurance rates doubled or more.
Randall
Verified Review
Super Claims Process
Very good.
Alisha
Verified Review
Just Hope Nothing Goes Wrong...
Don’t use the beacon. The savings aren’t worth the penalty. They say it won’t make your rates go up, but when I got in a no-fault accident, my rates doubled, and a representative said it was due to distracted driving. Dealing with that accident with State Farm was a nightmare.
Ann
Verified Review
Again, I have been satisfied until I saw the huge increase in payments
While handling a claim, they were very good. However, my cost has gone up very high, seemingly to recoup what you paid out, which is making it difficult for me to pay my mortgage with the increase.
Peter
Verified Review
Did Not Pay for Damage to My Property
They didn’t give me any money for damage to my house after 70-mile winds.
Wesley
Verified Review
Go Somewhere Else
I had a hail claim that took over a year to get anything done. They’ve raised prices, and the agents aren’t allowed to act on our behalf with the company either.
Daniel
Verified Review
Glass Coverage Is Bad
Shop around. The glass coverage is weak, and they wasted time with the claim, causing a repairable chip to spread. It took five days for them to move forward with the repair, and it ended up costing me an entire windshield.
Rodney
Verified Review
State Claims Assistance
SF collects premiums and does very little to assist policyholders with claims, particularly if the policyholder is not at fault.
Danny
Verified Review
Check Around
Average at best. State Farm insurance used to be the best, but something has changed. The insured now has to be more involved in the process. In the past, you could report your claim, take it to the repair facility, and wait for a call to pick it up. Now, you have to report the claim, wait on adjusters, verify the adjuster’s estimate, and then take it in for repair. Then, if the repair facility does not agree with the adjuster’s estimate, you may have to pay the difference yourself or go without your car for a long time while trying to get the adjusters to work out the difference. They’re just not the same company they used to be.
Ronald
Verified Review
My rates went up when my wife passed away. Same vehicle, with only one driver now. Why?
I was in a three-vehicle accident where the at-fault vehicle took off. State Farm listed me as at fault and raised my rates.

State Farm claims handling reviews vs. AAA and Allstate

State Farm customers gave the insurer a claims handling rating of 4.2 out of 5, outranking Allstate but trailing AAA. Insurify’s customers give claims handling ratings of 3.9 out of 5 to Allstate and 4.4 to AAA.

Allstate has a similar rating to State Farm but ultimately ranks lower, with dissatisfied customers citing unmet expectations throughout the claims process. AAA ranks ahead of both State Farm and Allstate, with reviews describing a smooth and quick claims process with clear communication.

Compare how Insurify’s customers rated these three companies for claims handling below.

Company
Average Score
State Farm4.2
AAA4.4
Allstate3.9

State Farm value for money reviews: Rated 3.9 out of 5

Insurify’s customers with State Farm policies give the insurer a value-for-money rating of 3.9 out of 5. Satisfied State Farm customers categorized pricing as fair or competitive for the quality of coverage received. Some negative reviews claim that premiums were too high and rising at each renewal.

Here are real reviews about State Farm’s value for money from Insurify’s customers with coverage from the insurer.

View State Farm customer reviews for value for moneyexpand/collapse
Veta
Verified Review
Great Broad Form Coverage
I have excellent broad form coverage. I haven’t found any other company offering the same coverage for less.
Debra
Verified Review
State Farm Insurance
Very happy with my car insurance with Progressive. I was paying almost $1,400 every six months for my car, but now I’m paying $520 for the same coverage.
Carles
Verified Review
Cheaper and better coverage: (1) comprehensive, (2) $25K medical, and (3) roadside service and towing. I got a better plan than I did with Farm B, and I had insurance with them for 18 to 20 years.
Cheaper and better coverage: (1) comprehensive, (2) $25K medical, and (3) roadside service and towing. I got a better plan than I did with Farm B, and I had insurance with them for 18 to 20 years.
Mark
Verified Review
State Farm Driver
Been with State Farm for over 50 years. They have always been solid. Every 2–3 years, I check around to see if they’re staying competitive, and they always are. Their safe driver rewards and rebates keep them even more competitive.
Jennifer
Verified Review
Never had a problem with them. Cheapest insurance around.
Check around, but State Farm is the cheapest. I've been a customer for over 20 years now.
Roy
Verified Review
The many quotes we receive from other carriers do not come remotely close to our State Farm premiums
I save money by bundling with State Farm. We have a great agent who looks out for ways to help us save money.
Wally
Verified Review
Good
Every time I’ve checked rates, State Farm has always been the lowest.
Curtis
Verified Review
Great value.
Excellent prices. Reputable brand.
Lance
Verified Review
Expensive
I’d prefer to pay a lower price for the insurance I’m getting from State Farm. Please provide a better quote than $299 a month for liability.
Latoya
Verified Review
It Was OK but a Bit Pricey for Me
It was OK, but a bit pricey for me. Make sure you have as few claims as possible, especially when it comes to roadside service.
Eldrianna
Verified Review
I’m Losing Money
I wouldn’t suggest them unless you have a perfect driving record or something like that. My premium kept going up for the smallest things. My premium is almost $600, which costs more than my monthly car payment, so I’m looking for a new insurance company.
Donato
Verified Review
Homeowners insurance feels reasonable, but you're charging me too much for car insurance. I've never had an accident.
I’ve never had an accident or made a claim, but they still charge me a little too much.
Bonnie
Verified Review
They immediately gave me a lower price than what I had to ask for from my previous insurance carrier.
They immediately gave me a lower price than what I had to ask for from my previous insurance carrier.
Allan
Verified Review
State Farm’s Excessive Rates
The only discount is Drive Safe & Save, and we use it. We drive less than 5,000 miles a year and still pay more for not driving.
Kendall
Verified Review
Looking for Better Rates
I’m wondering if I’m getting the best rates. I pay $1,850 annually for a 2,700-square-foot house valued at $850,000. A secondary dwelling with a 912-square-foot apartment upstairs and a 600-square-foot apartment downstairs is about $1,100. Car insurance is about $1,100 for a 2014 Honda CR-V. Can you beat any of these rates, or the combo?
Michael
Verified Review
High Insurance
State Farm is a good company, but their rates are way too high. I just switched supplemental plans for my wife to Mutual of Omaha and saved almost $200.00.

State Farm value for money reviews vs. AAA and Allstate

State Farm has a value-for-money rating of 3.9 out of 5, which ranks ahead of Allstate but behind AAA. Insurify’s customers give ratings of 3.4 out of 5 to Allstate and 4.5 to AAA for their value.

AAA has a higher value rating than State Farm and Allstate, with customers generally seeing its coverage as fairly priced. Allstate ranks lower than State Farm, with some reviews claiming its coverage isn’t worth the high premium.

Below, you can see how real Insurify customers rate each company’s overall value for money.

Company
Average Score
State Farm3.9
AAA4.5
Allstate3.4

State Farm policy transparency reviews: Rated 4.0 out of 5

State Farm earns a policy transparency rating of 4.0 out of 5 from Insurify customers. Positive reviews mention access to information online and helpful agents who can answer policy questions. Customers who left negative reviews say they lacked a clear understanding of their coverage and experienced surprise billing.

Read real reviews about policy transparency from Insurify’s customers with State Farm auto insurance.

View State Farm customer reviews for policy transparencyexpand/collapse
Elsie
Verified Review
Be Honest and Upfront
Always be honest and forthright with your information. Don't be afraid to ask questions about things you do not understand. It's best to ask rather than wonder what he or she is talking about.
Edwin
Verified Review
Good
Understandable, comprehensive, to the point, good prices.
Garness
Verified Review
Very good coverage
They explained the questions you asked so you can understand.
Larry
Verified Review
Best Insurance Company
Our options were explained very well to us in a way that we understood without getting confused.
Louie
Verified Review
Good
They were upfront with me.
Lee
Verified Review
Good Insurance
They are very efficient and everything is provided in writing for you to see.
Jerry
Verified Review
Excellent
They provide straightforward answers without any games.
David
Verified Review
Excellent
We didn't have to give a down payment.
Paris
Verified Review
Monthly bills arrive too close to the due date
My payments were very high after an accident. Also, the monthly bills arrive too close to the bill due date.
Larry
Verified Review
Watch your policy information. I’ve had times when the agent changed my coverage without my knowledge or consent. I once had to switch agencies because it happened so often.
Watch your policy information. I’ve had times when the agent changed my coverage without my knowledge or consent. I once had to switch agencies because it happened so often.
Diana
Verified Review
State Farm Is Not Transparent or a Good Value
State Farm was terrible, way too expensive, and not transparent about their policies.
Fayden
Verified Review
Great if you're on a family plan, poor if you have a solo policy
I'm currently insured, but the agent claimed I'm ineligible for another six months without any explanation.
Sandy
Verified Review
Mediocre
I’d like to be informed each year at renewal about what coverage I can do without as my car ages.
Philip
Verified Review
Mediocre
Good overall; however, each time there’s a price increase, the statement doesn’t explain what it’s for. If you call, and the broker isn’t available, they have to call State Farm and maybe get an answer. This is my second State Farm agent, since the first one was horrible and didn’t live up to any of his quotes.
Bethaney
Verified Review
Carefully Choose and Review Your Options
Did you know that if you have a claim, they can and will review your case and have the right to drop your coverage and refuse renewal? Yes, it’s true—you can be terminated for filing a claim.
Lillian
Verified Review
Not Satisfied With State Farm
I wouldn’t recommend State Farm because the price goes up higher and higher every month. It’s never the same, and they never say why.

State Farm policy transparency reviews vs. AAA and Allstate

State Farm’s policy transparency rating of 4.0 out of 5 ranks higher than Allstate but lower than AAA. Allstate has a rating of 3.8 out of 5, and AAA has a rating of 4.4.

Allstate has a lower rating than State Farm, and some customers feel their coverage is less robust than the policy they thought they were buying. AAA has a higher rating than State Farm and Allstate, and many customers feel their coverage is fairly easy to understand.

See how policy transparency ratings from real Insurify customers compare for these three insurers below.

Company
Average Score
State Farm4.0
AAA4.4
Allstate3.8

State Farm customer reviews: Read what over 21,491 Insurify customers have to say about State Farm

You can learn more about State Farm by reading reviews from more than 21,491 customers written during the last 12 months.

Carolyn
Verified Review
State Farm Insurance #1
Excellent.
Patricia
Verified Review
Good
They’re very expensive.
Rick
Verified Review
I like them, but I wish they were a little cheaper (or maybe a lot cheaper)
I think they’re all right, but they’re priced a little high. I keep seeing $58.59 whenever I look it up, and it always goes to Progressive. They want almost as much, so I’m not sure what to think.
Debby
Verified Review
State Farm
Good, but expensive.
Robert
Verified Review
State Farm
Costs too much like everyone else, but overall they’re really good.
Dave
Verified Review
I’m Going to Shop Around… Haven’t Filed a Claim in Years—So Why Are My Premiums Being Raised?
Shop around—they’re raising their premiums.
Adriene
Verified Review
Secure Your Ride with State Farm
Make sure it covers everything you need and that it’s budget-friendly. It is, however, a reliable insurance company, and I never had any complaints while being insured with them.
Cynthia
Verified Review
You Wanted My Opinion—Well, Here It Is
I’ve enjoyed doing business with State Farm. The only thing I don’t like is the extremely high premium rates. Sheesh! It’s outrageous. That’s the only reason I would ever want to move to a different insurance company. With as much business as I’ve done with State Farm over many, many years, it seems like I would get some sort of significant discount for my loyalty, but sadly I don’t. I guess loyalty doesn’t matter when it comes to high premiums. It’s disappointing that you can’t do anything to lower my rate.
Dethose
Verified Review
The premium is very high compared to other providers
The premium is very high.
Steve
Verified Review
High-Priced
Premiums are too high.
Michael
Verified Review
Fair
If you hit a deer, your policy triples.
Joseph
Verified Review
Average
Too expensive.
Nancy
Verified Review
Too Expensive
They continue to raise rates, even though I don't have any tickets or accidents.
Ruby
Verified Review
Average
Insurance keeps going up even if we don’t drive every day.
Jazmin
Verified Review
Too Expensive
Too expensive for a family policy.
Frank
Verified Review
Policies
Too expensive.

State Farm vs. AAA, Allstate, and GEICO

Overall, State Farm earns solid ratings from Insurify customers with policies from the insurer. While it generally scores short of AAA in most categories, State Farm ranks particularly well for customer service and claims handling, due to the helpfulness of its many local agents.

Below, you can see how State Farm stacks up against more top car insurance companies.

State Farm logo
CSAA logo
Allstate logo
GEICO logo
USAA logo
Nationwide logo
Average price
$78/mo*
Average price
$198/mo*
Average price
$125/mo*
Average price
$111/mo*
Average price
$77/mo*
Average price
N/A
Overall rating
Overall rating
Overall rating
Overall rating
Overall rating
Overall rating
Value for money
Value for money
Value for money
Value for money
Value for money
Value for money
Customer service
Customer service
Customer service
Customer service
Customer service
Customer service
Claims handling
Claims handling
Claims handling
Claims handling
Claims handling
Claims handling
Special highlight
AI-generated from 21491 user reviews
Customer service
Special highlight
AI-generated from 2990 user reviews
AAA members
Special highlight
AI-generated from 12465 user reviews
Accident forgiveness
Special highlight
AI-generated from 21141 user reviews
Teen drivers
Special highlight
AI-generated from 4359 user reviews
Members of the military community
Special highlight
AI-generated from 996 user reviews
Usage-based savings
Data in this table has been sourced from Insurify’s users who have indicated they are insured with the listed providers
User review collection and methodologyexpand/collapse

Insurify collects reviews from users on its platform who have successfully compared quotes, as well as users who have purchased a policy through Insurify.

These users complete an optional survey that asks them to review their experience with their current insurance company and rate the company on factors like customer service, claims handling, coverage availability, discounts, policy flexibility, policy transparency, and value for money. These ratings and reviews are then compiled and cleaned by our data team to bring you company-level insights from over 85,000 Insurify users.

Photo of an Insurify author
Writer: Katie PowersLicensed P&C Agent, Senior Insurance Editor

Qualifications:
  • Licensed auto and home insurance agent

  • 4+ years experience in insurance and personal finance editing

  • NPN: 20564519


Katie uses her knowledge and expertise as a licensed property and casualty agent in Massachusetts to help readers understand the complexities of insurance shopping.

MacKenzie Korris
Editor: MacKenzie KorrisLicensed P&C Agent, Senior Insurance Copy Editor

Qualifications:
  • Licensed property and casualty insurance agent

  • 10+ years editing experience

  • NPN: 21630969


MacKenzie Korris is an insurance copy editor with a producer’s license for property and casualty insurance in Missouri.