Make and Break: Five Auto Brands with the Most Car Accidents

Accidents can happen to anyone, but some drivers are more prone to them than others. According to the data, accident-prone drivers tend to favor a few major auto brands; and they may not be the ones you expect.

Traffic fatalities are on the rise, despite having steadily declined over the past decade. Over 38,000 people in the United States died from motor vehicle accidents in 2020, according to the NHTSA (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration). This represents a 7 percent increase from 2019. Though the causes for this shocking rise are not entirely clear, NHTSA analysis suggests that Americans increasingly adopted dangerous driving behaviors like speeding, cell phone usage, and failing to wear a seatbelt in 2020. Car accident injuries and deaths rose throughout the year, even as Americans drove fewer miles overall while sheltering at home in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic.

It goes without saying that getting into a car crash is one of the most dangerous things a driver can experience on the road. Even if all parties involved are fortunate enough to avoid personal injury, an auto accident still often means filing a police report and going through a claim process with an insurance company. An adjuster will have to get involved, and insurers will usually raise the at-fault driver’s rate. Drivers who are frequently involved in accidents can also have their driver’s license suspended or revoked.

Across the United States, about 11 percent of Americans have an at-fault motor-vehicle crash, from a fender bender to a serious incident, on their driving record. Data scientists at Insurify have already determined that accident rates vary significantly by car model. But do these differences still hold up when comparing car brands? To identify which auto brands have the highest proportion of accident-prone drivers, Insurify’s data science team analyzed its database of over four million car insurance applications.

Insights

• National averages. On average, 11 out of every 100 drivers in the United States have an at-fault accident on their record. Additionally, 43 percent of fatal car accidents in the United States involve multiple vehicles, according to the IIHS (Insurance Institute for Highway Safety).
• A most dangerous game. Driving a sports car may be fun, but it can also lead to serious outcomes. Four of the five “worst offenders”—car models with the largest share of at-fault accidents within each of the top five most accident-prone car makes—are considered sporty models, including performance-forward sedans, hatchbacks, and crossovers.
• The car brand with the lowest accident rate. This may come as a surprise: of all car makes, Porsche is the brand with the lowest rate of accidents. In fact, just 8.62 out of every 100 Porsche drivers have an at-fault accident on their record. That means Porsche motorists cause accidents 22 percent less often than the average United States driver. Even the Porsche model with the highest rate of accidents, the Porsche Boxster (9.89 per 100 drivers), still has a rate 10 percent lower than average.

Methodology

To identify the car makes with the most at-fault accidents, data scientists at Insurify, a site that helps users compare auto insurance rates, referred to their database of over 4 million car insurance applications.

To apply for car insurance, drivers input personal and vehicle information, including the make and model of the car they drive, their license plate number, and whether or not they have caused an accident in the past. To create the list below, the Insurify data science team compared the number of car owners with a prior at-fault accident against the total number of drivers for each make and model, determining the proportion of drivers with an at-fault accident on record. From this analysis they identified the top five car brands with the highest share of at-fault accidents. For each of the top five brands, they further identified the car model with the highest share of at-fault accidents and the car model with the lowest share of at-fault accidents. These car models are classified as the “worst offender” and the “most careful,” respectively.

Which Car Brands Have the Most At-Fault Accidents?

1. Subaru - 16% more accidents than average

2. Volkswagen - 14% more accidents than average

3. Hyundai - 12% more accidents than average

4. Mazda - 11% more accidents than average

5. RAM - 10% more accidents than average

Top 5 Automotive Brands with the Most Car Accidents

5. RAM

• RAM drivers with an at-fault accident: 12.12 out of 100 (10 percent above the national average)
• Worst Offender: RAM 2500 (13.79 out of 100 drivers reporting an at-fault accident on their record)
• Most Careful: RAM 1500 Tradesman (11.11 out of 100 drivers reporting an at-fault accident on their record)

Known for its heavy-duty pickup trucks, RAM starts off the list of the top five car makes with the most accidents. RAM drivers are over 10 percent more likely than average to report an at-fault collision on their record. Among all RAM models, the RAM 2500 is the “worst offender,” with RAM 2500 drivers causing accidents 25 percent more often than the national average. RAM motorists are a tad reckless across the board, however, as RAM is the only brand on this list with all its models having at-fault accident rates above average. The RAM 1500 Tradesman, RAM’s “most careful” model, still has an at-fault collision rate one percent higher than the national average.

4. Mazda

• Mazda drivers with an at-fault accident: 12.21 out of 100 (11 percent above the national average)
• Worst Offender: Mazda CX-3 (14.75 out of 100 drivers reporting an at-fault accident on their record)
• Most Careful: Mazda 626 (7.92 out of 100 drivers reporting an at-fault accident on their record)

Well-regarded for sharp styling, mechanical reliability, and an overall sporty feel, the Japanese Mazda brand provides a different sensibility than many other auto makes. Both RAM and Mazda drivers have a trait in common, however: lots of at-fault accidents. Overall, Mazda drivers are 11 percent more likely than the national average to report a motor vehicle accident on their record. Mazda CX-3 drivers are the brand’s worst offenders, causing accidents 34 percent more often than the average. Mazda 626 motorists are much safer, with a brand-low accident rate that is 28 percent less than the national average.

3. Hyundai

• Hyundai drivers with an at-fault accident: 12.34 out of 100 (12 percent above the national average)
• Worst Offender: Hyundai Genesis Coupe (15.32 out of 100 drivers reporting an at-fault accident on their record)
• Most Careful: Hyundai Equus (6.86 out of 100 drivers reporting an at-fault accident on their record)

Hyundai drivers have the third-highest share of at-fault accidents in the nation, compared to drivers of other car manufacturers. Based in South Korea, Hyundai produces cars recognized for their reasonable price and reliability, but it seems that not all Hyundai drivers are as reliable behind the wheel. This is particularly true for the brand’s worst offender—the Hyundai Genesis Coupe—a sporty, performance-oriented departure from their standard models. Drivers of this model have an accident rate that is a startling 39 percent higher than the national average. Many Hyundai models, however, have drivers with below average accident rates. This group is led by the Hyundai Equus, whose drivers are 37 percent less likely than average to cause an accident.

2. Volkswagen

• Volkswagen drivers with an at-fault accident: 12.59 out of 100 (14 percent above the national average)
• Worst Offender: Volkswagen Golf R (15.12 out of 100 drivers reporting an at-fault accident on their record)
• Most Careful: Volkswagen Routan (8.15 out of 100 drivers reporting an at-fault accident on their record)

Volkswagen produces a wide range of vehicles respected for their craftsmanship, performance, and uniquely German design sensibility. These qualities have made the brand attractive to many drivers, including, apparently, those prone to misadventures behind the wheel. Overall, Volkswagen drivers cause a motor vehicle collision 14 percent more often than the national average. Volkswagen’s Golf R—a speedy “hot hatch” model—is the brand’s worst offender, with its drivers a full 37 percent more likely than average to cause an accident. On the flip side, the manufacturer’s “most careful” drivers prefer the Volkswagen Routan, which boasts an accident rate nearly 26 percent lower than the national average.

1. Subaru

• Subaru drivers with an at-fault accident: 12.81 out of 100 (16 percent above the national average)
• Worst Offender: Subaru WRX (16.30 out of 100 drivers reporting an at-fault accident on their record)
• Most Careful: Subaru Tribeca (8.16 out of 100 drivers reporting an at-fault accident on their record)

Though the brand is better known for its easygoing and outdoorsy reputation, Subaru is the car brand with the most accidents. Its drivers cause motor vehicle collisions at a rate over 16 percent higher than the national average. The brand’s worst offender is the Subaru WRX, which has an accident rate a whopping 48 percent above average, making it one of the 10 most accident-prone models of any brand in the country. This finding dovetails with other research from the Insurify data science team, which also found the Subaru WRX to have the highest speeding ticket rate of any U.S. car model. Not all Subaru drivers are reckless, however. The Subaru Tribeca is the brand’s “most careful” model, with Tribeca drivers causing accidents at a rate 26 percent lower than the national average.

If you have any questions or comments about this article or would like to request the data, please contact insights@insurify.com.

Insurify Insights

Insurify’s team of data scientists and content specialists presents Insurify Insights, a series of automotive, home, and health studies focusing on the topics that impact us all. Through expert analysis of over 4 million car insurance applications and an array of top data sources, the Insurify Insights team produces new data-driven articles, trend analyses, regional superlatives, and national rankings every week. See Insurify Insights as featured in Forbes, Fox News, USA Today, NPR, and more.