Top 10 car models with the most car accidents
These collision-prone cars significantly exceeded the national average rate for at-fault accidents.
10. Subaru Impreza
Percentage of drivers with a prior at-fault accident on record: 10.3%
MSRP (base model): $19,795
IIHS overall safety evaluation: Good
Available as a compact sedan or hatchback, the Subaru Impreza landed in the final spot on the list, with 10.3% of drivers reporting an at-fault accident on record. Fortunately, the car boasts some impressive safety features to mitigate any damage.
Newer Impreza models offer driver-assisted technology that monitors traffic movement and warns if you veer out of your lane. A rear-vision camera reduces your risk of backup collisions, and all-wheel drive increases traction. The 2022–2023 Impreza even earned a spot on a more desirable list — the IIHS Top Safety Picks of 2022.
9. Kia Niro
Percentage of drivers with a prior at-fault accident on record: 10.4%
MSRP (base model): $26,590
IIHS overall safety evaluation: Good
Popular as a midrange family car, the Kia Niro is a crossover SUV that offers plenty of legroom while keeping emissions low with electric vehicle (EV) and hybrid options.
While the Niro has blind-spot protection and lane-centering technology, all-wheel drive is noticeably absent. The NHTSA also recalled certain 2017 Niro cars due to issues with the electric power-steering connector.
That said, missing features and recalls likely aren’t the main reasons Kia Niro drivers got into more at-fault accidents. Instead, it could be due to most Kia Niro drivers being in urban areas, where EVs are more popular. Urban areas typically have higher accident rates than rural areas.
8. Chevrolet Silverado LD
Percentage of drivers with a prior at-fault accident on record: 10.4%
MSRP (base model): $34,500
IIHS overall safety evaluation: Good
With an at-fault accident rate 37% higher than the national average, the Chevrolet Silverado LD is the only truck that made the list. Silverado drivers could be getting into more collisions because they often rack up extra miles at work. The light-duty pickup is a popular choice for construction and landscaping businesses.
If you’re a cautious driver, you have no reason to avoid this IIHS-approved model. A suite of advanced safety features comes standard in the Silverado, including front pedestrian braking, a rear-vision camera, lane-departure warning, a following-distance display, and automatic high-beam headlights.
7. Subaru XV Crosstrek
Percentage of drivers with a prior at-fault accident on record: 10.5%
MSRP (base model): $21,595
IIHS overall safety evaluation: Good
As a compact SUV with light off-road capabilities, the Subaru XV Crosstrek is an appealing choice if you need a car that handles both a weekend camping trip and your daily commute. The Crosstrek’s 182-horsepower engine and high ground clearance appeal to adventurers.
The accident rate for drivers of this car is less attractive, at 38% higher than the national average. However, recent Crosstrek models have modern safety features, and driver-assisted technology identifies potential hazards that could help Crosstrek drivers lower their collision rates in the future.
6. Subaru WRX
Percentage of drivers with a prior at-fault accident on record: 10.7%
MSRP (base model): $29,605
IIHS overall safety evaluation: Good
The sporty WRX is the third Subaru model on the list. This rally-inspired car clearly appeals to thrill-seekers. Subaru WRX drivers are taking full advantage of the 271-horsepower engine, with 13.6% reporting a speeding citation. They’re not always the best at owning up to their accidents, either. Subaru WRX drivers made the Insurify list of models with the most hit-and-runs in 2022.
Still, the WRX has a good balance of performance and safety features and was a 2022 IIHS Top Safety Pick+. The car also earned top marks for crash avoidance and mitigation, suggesting user error may largely influence its high accident rate.
5. Toyota GR86
Percentage of drivers with a prior at-fault accident on record: 10.8%
MSRP (base model): $29,900
IIHS overall safety evaluation: Good
Toyota GR86 drivers have an at-fault accident rate 42% higher than the national average, placing the car midway through the list. Billed as an accessible hot rod, the sleek and speedy model appeals to drivers looking for razor-sharp handling backed by a turbocharged 228-horsepower engine.
This sports car isn’t only about performance, though. Toyota GR86 drivers may be more accident-prone, but the model offers numerous safety features, including a pre-collision braking system, lane-departure warning, automatic high beams, and adaptive cruise control. The IIHS even named the 2022