Best Renters Insurance in Tampa (2025)

In exchange for ocean breezes and year-round sunshine, renters in Tampa, Florida, face the occasional hurricane or tropical storm. That’s why renters insurance is a smart idea.

A renters insurance policy can protect your belongings from common risks in the Sunshine State, including storms and other risks, like theft or fire. It also provides liability coverage if someone is injured in your rental home. While it isn’t a legal requirement, your landlord or rental company may require it as a part of your lease agreement.

Let’s look at what renters insurance in Tampa covers, the best insurers in the area, and how to save on your policy.

How renters insurance works in Tampa

Renters insurance in Tampa is fairly straightforward. Policies generally include three main coverages: personal property, liability, and additional living expenses.^[1]

Purchasing renters insurance is simple. You can usually sign up online in just a few minutes:

1. Request a quote. Compare policies from multiple insurance companies in Tampa, reviewing coverages and exclusions.

2. Choose coverage limits. Create an inventory of your belongings to get an idea of how much coverage you need.

3. Select a deductible. A higher deductible typically lowers your premium but increases your out-of-pocket costs if you file a claim.

4. Choose a policy. Pick the policy that best balances coverage with price.

The insurance industry uses factors like your location, property coverages, deductible, and claims history to determine the cost of your renters policy. The Florida Office of Insurance Regulation oversees rates and licensing for all renters insurance companies.

Filing a renters insurance claim

If you need to file an insurance claim, the process is usually straightforward. In cases of theft or vandalism, you’ll need to submit a police report, then proceed with your claim. Otherwise, most insurers let you report the event and submit documentation online or through their mobile app. You’ll likely need pictures of the damage, and it’s helpful to have a home inventory so you can report the value of any damaged items.

Get a Fast, Free Renters Insurance Quote

Protect your stuff and find affordable peace of mind

Get My Quote

Secure. Free. Easy-to-use.

4.8/5 (7,669+ reviews)

Best renters insurance companies in Tampa

Many quality companies offer renters insurance in Tampa. The best renters insurance company for you will depend on your budget, coverage needs, and the specific risks where you live.

Allstate offers customizable coverage and multiple discounts to fit different budgets. GEICO is ideal for renters who want to bundle policies and service members looking for military discounts.

Lemonade is known for its fast, digital claims process and affordable premiums. Progressive has highly rated mobile apps and discounts for bundling multiple policies. And State Farm has a large network of local Tampa agents who can assist with signups and claims.

Here are our top picks and their average monthly rates for a policy with $15,000 in personal property coverage.

Insurance Company	Average Monthly Premium	Best For
Allstate	$18	Discounts
GEICO	$15	Military members
Lemonade	$12	Affordability
Progressive	$14	Digital experience
State Farm	$15	Agent support

What renters insurance covers in Tampa

A renters insurance policy covers your personal contents and protects your finances from unexpected events, such as natural disasters, theft, and legal claims. Here are the primary types of coverage most renters insurance policies include:^[1]

• 

  Personal property coverage

  If a covered event damages your belongings, such as clothes, furniture, electronics, and other possessions, personal property coverage can help replace them. Some insurers pay the replacement cost, meaning the price to replace items at current prices. Others pay the actual cash value, which factors in depreciation.

• 

  Liability coverage

  Liability insurance covers medical and legal costs if someone sustains injuries in your rental home or you accidentally cause property damage.

• 

  Additional living expenses coverage

  Also known as loss of use, this coverage provides reimbursement for temporary housing and related costs if your rental property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered peril.

While terms vary by insurance company, policies typically cover many of the most common risks in Tampa, including:

• Fire

• Smoke damage

• Theft

• Vandalism

• Wind damage

• Lightning

• Hurricanes

• Water damage from plumbing leaks

Renters insurance generally doesn’t cover floods, earthquakes, or normal wear and tear. It also often excludes valuables that exceed policy limits, like jewelry, antiques, or collectibles. But you may be able to add policy endorsements, such as jewelry insurance.

Unique considerations for renters insurance in Tampa

Renters insurance is essential in Tampa to protect against hurricanes, tropical storms, and other risks. While a standard policy covers theft, fire, and windstorms, you may need extra insurance protection for other perils, such as:

• Flooding: Hurricanes and tropical storms can cause heavy rain and storm surge. Standard renters insurance doesn’t cover flood damage, so you may want to consider a separate flood insurance policy from the National Flood Insurance Program or a private insurer.

• Sinkholes: Florida is susceptible to sinkholes, which renters insurance typically doesn’t cover. Tampa renters might want to add sinkhole coverage to protect their belongings.

• Humidity and mold: Florida is the most humid state in the U.S., which is unsurprising considering that the Atlantic Ocean and Gulf of Mexico surround it. Persistent moisture can lead to mildew or mold damage, so it’s a good idea to check if and when your policy covers this type of damage.

When reviewing your insurance coverage, make sure your policy explicitly includes windstorm and hurricane damage. Also, check if it covers sinkholes and mold, or whether you can add them as endorsements. If you’re not sure if you should purchase flood insurance, the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s flood maps can show you whether you live in a high-risk area.^[2]

How to save on renters insurance in Tampa

Renters insurance is relatively affordable in Tampa, ranging from $15 to $23 per month, on average, depending on how much coverage you want. Here are a few ways you can lower your premium even more:^[3]

• 

  Shop around

  Comparing insurance options and quotes can help you find the most protection for the best rate.

• 

  Bundle policies

  Some companies offer discounts if you bundle two or more policies, such as auto and renters insurance.

• 

  Raise your deductible

  You can lower your premium by selecting a higher deductible. Just make sure to choose a deductible amount you could afford after a loss.

• 

  Improve home security

  You may qualify for a discount if you install security devices, since it lowers the insurer’s risk.

• 

  Maintain good credit

  Some insurers use credit-based insurance scores when determining rates, and they charge lower rates if you have a healthy credit history.

Renters insurance in Tampa FAQs